Money it's a gas
Grab that cash with both
hands and make a stash
( f l e ˜ - 3m0 6 U 3 ,
b˜˜
PYiCdkLU NUAUYHbLe 3mU czpe6u
u zpa.uomHo ux ymau)

˜
Pink Floyd (*Money,)



pelrb n o i i ˜ o perynn-

POBaHMM C/eIlTeJlbHOCTM ,
O@@WO˜H˜˜ o ˜na˜˜lii
IX
Ka3aXCTaHCKMM 3aKOHO-
-------

&a˜enbcTso˜r-e=--
X O M A a H H b l e KOMnaHMM
W C T O MMeHYDTCII <<KOH-
TPOJlMPYeMblMM MHOCT-
PaHHblMM KOMnBHMFIMM,,,
a npasosoA M e X a H H 3 M
p e r y n M p o B a H m MX Ae-
- <<npaBM-
IlTeJlbHOCTM
naJ s a ˜ o ˜ o ˜ a ˜ e n b c ˜ ˜ o
o
KOHTPOnMPYeMblX MHOCT-
PaHHbIX KOMnaHMRX)).
fl TaKXe O ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ M H R K I BOPraHM3auMMC UenbK)
TCFI HblX l o ˜ ˜ ˜ k l ˜ t p l f i )
fl03BOnMT O & C ˜ ˜ C I M T S
H H ˜ MOMeHT nOnY'4a-

M ˜ K C M M ˜ ˜ p ˜ 6 O 1 n nptI
3 a u l . 1 ˜c˜ o e i T O ˜ K M p e ˜ H a˜ seaeH.lwe
s
pacnpo-
ece 3 y
eT 6onbuee nOny'ieHMe n˜ H b ˜ ˜.
6ns˜eca. 3TOM aKKYMYnMPOBaHHaR n p M 6 b l n b B ynpae-
CTpaHeHMe TO'4Ka 3peHMR MeX,4yHapOAHOrO
6yp,e˜0 6 n a r a ˜ b c f lno
M, KOHeCIHO, CTOMT npM3HaTb, .IT0 M3Ha- n R l o U e G KOMflaHMM
0 r p R f l y u e f i KOHqMHe 3 p b l O@@WOPOB. ˜ P M
H M ˜ K O ˜ ˜˜ O ˜ O B O ˜ COOTBeTCTBMM C
W n b H O 3 a n o x e H H b l f i npMHuMfl AeRTeflbHOCTM CTaBKe B

3TOM yKa3blBaeTCR HeCKOnbKO flPMq-IMH: YXeC-
O@@WO˜HMX O M ˜ ˜ H˜ MJ ˜ o˜ H o C T ˜
(c B CylqeC-
K
TOreHMe MHOrMMM rOCyAapCTBaMM KOHTPOnR O @ @ U O ˜ H OI˜ ˜P M ˜ M K ˜ M C ˜ .
O
E c n ˜ n a A e n e u - KpynHaR KOMnaHMR.
3 a B3aMMOOTHOLUeHMRMM Pe3MAeHTOBAaHHblX TBOBaHMR B npMpOAe K O M ˜ ˜ ˜ H MnOnH0CTbD
M) B
A o p o m a U a R csoefi p e n y ˜ a u ˜ e f i , o H a He
c o o T s e T m o e a n KonuenuMM c a M o r o ((DPM˜M- TO
rOCyAapCTB C KOMflaHMRMM O @ @ W O ˜ H ˜ I X
6yae˜
recKoronMUaa,, p a 3 p a 6 0 ˜ a H H o A u e HecKonb-
e CKpblBaTb C00M CBR3M C O @ @ W O ˜ H O ˜
IOPHC,QMKUM˜˜, e n e H a n p a e n e t i H a R nonMTMKa
u
KOT˜ICFIV e T ˜ a 3 a p M ycoaepwe˜crsosa˜˜oR O M ˜ ˜ H COOTBeTCTBeHHO, H e 6 y a e ˜ C K P b l -
n . K M˜˜,
MeXJ,yHapOflHblX 0praHM3aL(Mfi M, KaK CJleAC-
HecKonbKo coTeH n e T ˜ a 3 a f i .To ecTb o T g e n e - BaTb fiOXOAbl A ˜ H H O @ U O P H O ˜ KOMnaHHM

TBMe, OTKa3 OTAenbHblX CTpaH OT HeKOTOPblX
HMe n v l r H o c n n , npaeoeoro cTaTyca, oTeeTc- OT c B o e r o r o c y A a p c T B a , TeM 6onee ecnM B
3neMeHTOB ((o@@LUO˜HOCTM)) nOCpejJCTBOM
TBeHHOCTM (KBK n p a B M n 0 , orpaHMcleHHofi), CO˜CTB˜HHOM
rOCynapCTBe H e 3Ha'-IMTenbHM
p e @ O p ˜ bCBOMX HaJlOrOBblX
l CMCTeM (l/lpnaH-
K ˜ n pr, o n n a ˜ a ˜ fT.A.). Xe
aKTMBOB B n a A e n b U a KOMflaHMM OT TeX IlOJlMTMqeCKMe PMCKM ( H ˜ u M O H ˜ ˜ M ˜ ˜ ˜
AMR, Ml
napaMeTpOB c a ˜ 0 fKOMflaHMM. H˜CMOTPR
i
V ˜ ˜ B ˜ C TCneuManMcT no o @ @ w o p a ˜
H˜I˜ Ha H e c ˜ a 6 M n b H a RnOnMTM.leCKaR CMTyal(Mfl,
Am. nennep B c ˜ o e f p a 6 o ˜ e TO, TO patiee n o a M T a m e oTHocMnMcb c He-
i r p d X , Q a ˜ ˜ ˜ b I e / B ˜ e ˜ ˜ b l@ ˜ M K T ˜ I T.&),
((AHTMo@- KOH e M
@ w o p ) ) e u e B ZOO2 rosy n p o r ˜ o a m p o e a n , .D,OBepMeM K <(IOPMflMWCKMM JlMUaM)), CqMTaR OTHOCMTenbHO a a 6 ˜ n b ˜ 3aKOHOAaTenbC-
oe
'-IT0 B TereHMe 6 n ˜ x a f i w '4eTblpeX-nRTM n e T
˜x 3T0 @MKuMefi, B KOHqe KOHUOB ˜ O ˜ ˜ L L I M H C T B OTBO. B e a b H e CeKpeT, .IT0 OAHMM H3 OCHOBHblX
MOXHO (CnocraBMTb ˜pecr)) M C ˜ O ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ @aicropos yeoaa KanMTana 3 a p y 6 e m ˜ e n n e ˜ c ˜
HOCO3HanO n o ˜ p e 6 ˜ o B AaHHOM HHCTMTYTe
c˜b
Ha MM
O@@UO˜OB B MOflenflX, MCnOnb3yeMblX npkl B W R X pa3BMTMR flpeAilpMHMMaTenbCTBa KaK MMeHHO B˜ICOKML?YPOBeHb BHYTPMnOnMTM-
oco6o pnc˜oeofi@ e p b ˜ e R T e n b H o m . (˜ehcrenn n
no
eeaeHMM c o e p e M e H H o r o M e m y H a p o A H o r o c A qecKMx PMCKOB eran˜3a4˜˜
T a m e MOXHO OTMeTMTb UenM IlOflBneHMR
6 ˜ 3 ˜ e c KOHWHO, .CJleAyeT COrJlaCMTbCR C
a. MnM aMHMCTMM KanMTanOB, MMeBUlMe MecTO
@eHOMeHa O @ @ U O P H ˜ I X K O M ˜ ˜ B H M ˜ ˜ ,
M3Ha-
MHeHMeM CneqManMCTOB, qTO K HaCTORqeMY B MCTOPMM MHOrMX rOCy,QapCTB, B WCTHOCTM,
CHr, - TOMY
BpeMeHM KOHL(enUMR ((O@@UOPHOTO 6 ˜ 3 ˜ e -q a n b i i o H a n p a s n e n n b l x Ha eeAeHMe B H e w H e - B HeflaBHeM flpOUlnOM CTpaH
T O ˜ ˜ O B onepau˜fi K)PMC,QMKL&˜RXH W ˜ K O G
c no˜˜sepme˜˜e).
ca)) B n o r o H e 3 a B
˜IX
M M H M M M ˜ ˜ a nMr o B˜ l x
H˜ o ˜ b
0 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e n M, aeras n o n y n e r a n b H b l M M e x a - MOXHO
b˜ H a n O r 0 ˜ 0 f H a r p y 3 ˜ 0 f M, COOTBeTCTBeHHO, C
i i OTMeTMTb, CITO H a npaKTMKe MHO-
M ˜ K C M M ˜ ˜ ˜nHpO G b l n ˜ . r M e KOMnaHMll C M M e H e M name CTapaloTCR
U e n b l o flOnY'4eHHR ˜6
HM3MOM, M ˜ ˜ ˜ X ˜˜ H n 0 r 0 0 6 n 0 ˜ e ˜ M R
aMR MnM,
TO ananorwino 6 y ˜ n e p e M e u e H m n p o m 3 -
y
e u e xyme, oTMblsaHMR A e H e r n p e e p a m - a @ ˜ w ˜ p o e TecHylo a @ c p ˜ n w ˜ p o e a ˜ ˜ o n b
a˜b
.O
I
T
soncrea T o s a p o s M a c c o e o r o flo˜pe6nf2HMR143
naCb B a 6 c y p ˜
CUMepTBblMM a y U a M M ) ) B BMAe C o @ @ W O ˜ H O˜˜ ˜ ˜ f l a ˜ M e f i - ˜ n e p a
a0 MAeHTMrHOCTM H ˜ M M ˜ H O B ˜TO- M ˜ ˜
3anaAHblX CTpaH B CTpaHbl D r 0 - B o C T O ˜ H O ˜ ˜ BflnOTb
HOMMHanbHblX ˜ ˜ p e ˜ ˜ o p o e / e n a f i e n b ˜ e ˜ , H
6naro-
A ˜ M Mn,p o ˜ 3 o w e p , w e r o c
B CBR˜M
n0KyflKl-I KOMnaHMM B BMAe naKeTa AOKYMeH- ˜ O B H O O@@UIOPHO˜ KOMIlaHMM. O T J ˜ M W ˜
M˜˜ B
=weeoh
TOE 6 e 3 K ˜ K M X - n M 6BKTMBOB, MCnOnb30BaHMe
0 nPMRTHblM H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O B ˜ I M
KJlMMaTOM, ABHHOM CJlyclae M O X e T 6 b l ˜ b M W b B nOflOn-
n
-
a66pee˜a˜ypax,
pa6oreii c ˜ n o fBi pewone.
ee B npecTynHblx UenRx M T.A. HMTenbHblX KOCBeHHO YKa-
TOM
3 b r e a t o q n x H a ry Mnw MHYD ((O@@WOPHOCT˜))
O A H ˜ K nonaraehn, r ˜ Ha f i a n ˜ b l f i MO-
O o YclM˜blBaRMHOrOneTHDlo MCTOpMlo 0@-
- B.V.,
cue p a H 0 CnllCblBaTb @WOpHblx K O M ˜ ˜ H M ˜ ,˜ p e 6 ˜ o M r ˜
no c TBOp- N.V., B.V.I., Ltd. M T.A. (06uepacnpo-
MeHT M B nepCfleKTMBe
'ieCKylo M306p‚¬!˜a˜enbH0CTb I l p e a n p M H M M a -
CO C'ieTOB O@@LLIOPH˜I˜
KOMnaHMM fl0 PRAY CTpaHeHHaR npaKTMKa M3BeCTHblX KPynHblX
CyueCTBeHHblX npM'4UH. ˜ K O H O M M ˜ ˜ C K ˜ ˜enefi, o e p e ˜ e ˜ ˜ cnemp uenefiC O ˜ A ˜ H M R K ˜ p n ˜ p a ˜ M f i ) . no MHCHMIO K O M ˜ ˜ H M ˜ ˜
3˜0,
c blfi
FI
6 y ˜ cen ˜
q e n e ˜ 0 0 6 p a 3 ˜ 0 o @b u o p ˜ o f i o p ˜ b ˜A a H H b l X K O M ˜ B H V B ˜ C b M a 6 0 n b ˜ o RM
˜˜ @ Ie
@ o c o 6 ˜ ˜ ˜ ao B ea M t 0 CO CTOpOHbl
o˜ p ˜ b
p a 3 ˜ 0 0 6 p a 3 H b l h H ˜ C T O R CTaTbR H e MMeeT K O H T ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ H T3O e M u M K O B B OTHOWeHMM
aB/
( ˜˜R
seoeHn9 M e M y H a p o A H o r o 6 n 3 ˜ e c aecbMa
e
CBOMM ˜ a 3 ˜ a q MX a˜ ˜ ˜a e - TO MY noc- Aaxe npv
e n˜3
0.IeBMAHa fJlR MHOrMX (OT @ M ˜ H C ˜ ˜ C K M X
nM4 o @ @ w o p ˜ o f KoMnaHMM
i HanMrMM
BRUeHO 6 o n b w o e KOnM'-ieCTBO ˜neL(ManbH0fi ( ( n 0 ˜ 0 3 p M ˜ e n b H 0 f i )a 6 6 p e s ˜ a ˜ y p b r .
)
M MenKMX K O M ˜ ˜ H 0 KpYnHblX PeCneKTa-
AM˜
cnyrae
˜opnopau˜fi). o ˜ o n m a l o q a ˜ c c l n ˜ ˜ e p a r y p b ˜ ) . B
6enb˜blx np moM enanenb4t.1, HaMepe-
O ˜ H ˜ CJleAyeT
KO
r n o 6 a n ˜ 3 ˜a M p 0˜˜ 0 f i
˜˜ 3KOHOMMKM. HM3KMe OTMeTMTb, '-IT0 B HCKO- B a D u H e C R p a 3 B M B a T b f l ˜ n r ˜ ˜ p ˜ qM b l f
˜
n p M 6 b l n b H b l i 6 ˜ 3 ˜ e 6yay rOTOBbl flnaTMTb
crporoe ˜ 0 6 n l o p . e ˜ ˜ e
TOP˜IX C n y r a R x
Hanoroebre O a e K M M BeAeHMe M e x g y H a p o A H o r o c.
K O M M ˜ ˜ . ˜ ˜ C K O i˜˜˜ b l
˜af B O@@UOPH˜IX OPMC- 6 ˜ 3 ˜ e r e p 3 o @ @ u I O P H ˜ I ˜ OMnaHMM
ca K cooTseTcreyloUMe H a n o w B c s o e M rocyaapc-
ee
MHT˜PH˜T˜ Tee, H e y'raMBaR o T r e T n o u M no a @ @ ˜ n ˜ ˜ p o -
M O X e T 6 b l T b BblrOAHblM H e TOnbKO AnFl
AMKUMRX, pa3BMTMe M BblCOKMX
e n a a e n b ˜ e e HO M PC˜R rocynapasa, K l o p ˜ c -
˜ e x ˜ 0 J l o r b l(f i ˜ H O B ˜ H Hn˜ K T p O H H b l e , BaHHblM O@@WOPH˜IM KOMflaHMRM, T.K. 3TO
M 3 eI ˜
nna˜ofia rapatiwlo M 6 e 3 o n a c n o c r b
- BCe 3T0 )
T ˜ ˜ H ˜ ˜ K ˜ V I H TOnbKO C ˜ O C O ˜ C T B ˜ AMK4MM KOTOPOrO flpMHa)3,neXaT AaHHble nenReTcfl 3
˜T
c o 6 c r ˜ e ˜ ˜6ns˜eca 6 y . q q e ˜Mano KT0
.
oro
BnaAenbUbl. Koner˜o, ˜ K c n y˜ a u H e f l s n s -
Mq B
T
yKpennenMro o @ @ w o p ˜ o r o ˜ 3 ˜ e c a .
6
Enron
DTCR BeCbMa PaCnPOCTpaHeHHblMM, OAHaKO, xoreT n o e ˜ o p m b eranbHylo c y ˜ b 6 y
n
˜ O ˜ T O M ˜ , C'4MTaIOT HeKOTOPble Cne-
KaK
DKOCa,
no- K npMMepy, o @ @ I U O ˜ H ˜ ˜ I
KOMnaHMR C03AaHa MnM T.K. MHOrMe 3APaBOMblCJlR˜Me
u,ManMCTbl, H a AaHHblfi MOMeHT 6 o n b u e
yn-
KaK x o n g ˜ ˜ , r o o 6 p a 3 y r o KOMnaHMfl,
˜a˜ M e H e A X e p b l OC03HaDT, '-IT0 ˜ a f i ˜ b(ZMrPbl B
le
AOBMHbI MeX,4yHapOAHOrO 6 ˜ 3 ˜ e BeneTCR
ca
o n p e a e n e ˜ ˜ o foi n e f i sepo-
o @ @ w o ˜ ˜ I ) )c
C YWTOM O@@UOPH˜IX K O M ˜ ˜ B H(Vf I l˜p˜˜ q e ˜ paBnRloLU,aR MHOCTpaHHblMM KOMnaHMRMM, A
f l e f i c r e y l o q v ˜ ˜ a 3 n ˜ r ˜ bp1 xM o t i a x MMpa
ep 5ITHOCTM B 6 y ˜ y q 6 y ˜ paCKpblTbl ( r e p e 3
e˜ v
er
3T0 nPaKTMKYeTCR ˜ O ˜ ˜ ˜ W M H C T KPYnHblX
BOM
M MM˜DUMMM p e a n b n o e n p o ˜ 3 ˜ o ˜ c r B
˜ o p n o p a u ˜ hM ,A 0
) s o . ˜˜HKOBCKM˜
OnepaUMM, UCnMB)) M H @ O P M ˜ ˜ H M
M3BeCTHblX CMX n O p
o@- 3TOM CJlyclae O f l T l l M a n b H a R OPraHM3aUMR M T.A:).
aKTyanbHblM RBnReTCR BOnpOC, KaKaR
xonamra, ˜ @ @ ˜ K T M B Hynpae-
npy
@ w o p ˜ O P H ˜ M K U M R RBnReTcR ˜ a ˜ 6 o n e e H a ˜ M ˜ ˜ a n b H3b a e o ˜ o ˜ a ˜ e MHO-
O˜ l˜ nb˜ ˜ea

n e H M e M KOOPAMHaU,MR .QefiCTBMh ( Q ˜ ˜ o K ) rwx rocy˜apcis, KaK npaenno. tie c o a e p x a T
TO^ n
o n ˜ ˜ ˜ a n bA ˜ Ro pf e a n ˜ 3 a ˜ n ˜ n M
n i
6onee TOrO, CTpaHbl C KOHTPOnMPYeMblX K O M ˜ ˜ H Hp˜ M O T H O e
r a˜ , OTAenbHblX CneUMaJlbHblX aKTOB B OTHOUeHMM
M H O ˜ M3He˜-CX˜M˜I.

0 @ @ W O p H b l ˜K O M ˜ ˜ H U ˜ B ,HeKOTOpblX
HO ˜
MCflOnb30BaHMe HloaHCOB 3aKOHOAaTenbCTBa
o @ @ L U O ˜ H O K ˜) P M ˜ M K ˜ M ˜ ˜ ˜
˜ B nPOTMBOBeC
crpanax n p ˜ c y r m y e˜ a 6 o HOPM (B OCHOB-
p
r
CTpaH (KBK O(˜)@UOPH˜IX, TaK M HeO@@UIOP-
M e X f l y H a p O A H b l M OpraHM3auMRM ( 0 3 C P )
a COOTBeTCTBylo˜Mel p a B M n a IlPMMCHRDTCFI,
ClaCTb BHYTPMHauMOHanbHOTO H a n o - i YCTaBHOrO KanMTana lOPMAM'ieCKOr0 nMU,a-
˜ e p e s m n e ˜ ˜ a OH M M e e T 10 M 6onee
˜ ˜ o ˜ o n a ˜ e n b c rpsea y)n, M p y l o q M x
r ecnM @ M H C K M a K u M o H e p BnaAeeT H e M e i i e e
˜ MnM
npoue˜meo n c x y l o u v l x ˜ K W A˜ T O DPWM-
O ˜ ˜ O X ˜ H M ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ M U ˜ HOT O B10% ˜ K U M ˜ .
noxonoe r ˜O
T
f l a ˜ ˜ b lBe R H M R O C H Y ˜ M C ˜ a ˜ HCKO-
˜ me
˜ K ˜ - ˜ ˜ C K O T O J I M ˜ ˜ - H ˜ PKOTOPO˜,B˜CBOD˜ ,
˜˜M,J˜ HT
HOCTM 0 @ @ ˜ 0 P H b l X O M ˜ ˜ H V I ˜ .
K
TOPblX CTpaH CHr, K KOTOPblM MOXHOOTHeCTM
,KnPMMePY, OClePenb, nOJly'4aeT )JOXOjl, B rOCyfiapcTBe C
aHan0MClHblA CBOnHOPM fi

Kasaxcrati (06 3 ˜ ˜ 6 o n nonpo6noH W ˜ ) ,
ee
˜a˜6onee J7brOTHblM H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O O ˜ ˜ O XT˜ H H4aCTb,
OrW ˜ M
( O A H O ˜M3 npOnBMHYTblX
˜CTOHMM, A e nOpOrOBble3HaqeHMfl B OTHOLUe-
r n p ˜ 6 b l DpM,l3,MlreCKOrOJlMua,
n˜ OTHOCRLqaRCR
OTHOlLleHMM C T ˜ ˜ H )
MMeHyeTCR
K pe3MneHTy, BKnlo'4aeTCR B er0 nanoroo6na-
MM 0 KOHTPOnMPYeMblX MHOCT- HMM KOHTPOflMPYeMblX MHOCTpaHHbtX KOMna-
HMR aHanorMrlHb1 B 6enopyccu˜
QMHCKMM.
HX KopnopaqMRx)) ( C o n t r o l l e d F o r e ˜ g n rae˜b˜finoxon.
f l p ˜ no0 rocynapcreou c n b r o ˜ ˜ b ˜ r n
tions - CK, 1962r.),˜.e.MHocrpaHHblx ycTaHoBneHa e e c b M a y n p o q e H H a R M o n e n b TOM
˜ a n o r o o 6 n o x B ˜ ˜˜ ˜ O O T H O U J ˜ H H ˜
e˜ MM
B C O@-
RX, KOHTPOnMPYeMblX Pe3HneHTOM. H˜JIO˜OO˜˜OX˜HM˜M
nOHMMaeTCR rOCyaapC-
a MMeHHO nlo6a˜
MnaHMR WMTaeTCR K O H T ˜ O ˜ M ˜ ˜ ˜ M O ˜ ˜ ,
@UOPH˜IMM KOMnaHMRMM, TBO, B KOTOPOM CTaBKa H a n O r a COCTaBnReT
6onee 1/3 CTaBKM, o n p e f l e n f l e ˜ o ! ? B
aMepHKaHCKMe aKL(M0Hepbl B COBOKYn- OnJlaTa A e H b r a M M ( n e p e 8 0 ˜ )O @ @ U O ˜ H O ˜ He
0 6 n a r a e ˜ c*O@@UOPH˜IM c60-
˜
6onee 50% c
COOTB˜TCTBMM H ˜ ˜ O ˜ OKoneKcoM, MnM
B˜IM
Kounatim
BnaAeloT ronocylaqMx
. f l p ˜ ˜ M ˜ P M K ˜ H CaKqMOHep p a 3 M e p e 15%. Cflenye˜
POM)) B OTMeTMTb, MMelOTCfl 3aKOHbl 0 K O H @ M ˜ ˜ H ˜ M ˜ ˜ ˜ H O C T M
3TOM KM˜˜
˜ ˜ H H O AclT0 @MH˜HCOBO˜MH@OPM˜˜MMM˜MMH@OPM˜˜MU
H CflaBaTb OT'leTHOCTb 00 ˜OCCM˜CKO˜
3aKOHOAaTenbCTBO e o o 6 q e
cnyx6e
HHCl H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O B O ˜ CLUA, ecnM OH H e MMeeT HOPM, YCTaHaBnMBalO˜MX0t06b1k 0 KOMllaHMRX, KOTOpble n03BOnRloTCOXpaHRTb
T ˜ A 0 @BKTM'-I˜cKOM

˜anoroo6noxe˜˜u
1 M 6onee npOueHTaMM rOnOCylolL(MX
0 PeXMM AOXOflOB OT o@- BJlanWlbUe MMyueCTBa
MnM @ ˜ K T M ˜ ˜ C K a nM n b u e noxona.
Bn ˜ e


conepxm n o n o x e H m , KacaloqMecrr H a n o r o - KPHT˜PHROnpeneneHuR
c o o ˜ ˜ e ˜ c ˜ s y l p,onM a n y a c -
o ˜ q ero n e M npenycMoTpeti
o @ @ u r o p ˜ o c r nTOA MnM MHOA D P M ˜ ˜ , M K ˜ M H
o 6 n o x e A o˜ o˜ o e p e s ˜ n e oTp,eRTenb-
˜x n
aeTcR B ˜ a n o r o o 6 n a r a e ˜ b ˜ i 0 x 0 ˜
lf ˜˜a
HOCTM O@@WOPHCIX K O M ˜ ˜ H M W . f l p ˜ - c T a s K a H a n o r a c o c r a e n R e T 1/3 M M e H e e
Hanom, ynnarh- TOM
KaHc˜oroaKuclo˜epa.
n0 CpaBHeHMlO C Ka3aXCTaHCKMM aHanOrOM.
OTnMCIMTWlbHaRO C O ˜ W H O C OTeCleGTBeHHOrO

AOXOpa K O H T P O ˜ H P Y ˜ M ˜ ˜
KOMnaHMM
- ero ,qekcrsylolL(yo c r a s ˜ ˜ a s a x c r a ˜ c -
y
perMnpaqMM, a a c l r ˜ ˜ b ˜ n pa ˜ o 3 a ˜ o ˜ o ˜ a ˜ e nn b p arH˜ a M y B o n p o c y
oc Ho
˜M ˜a YV-IMT˜IB˜R
naKOHMqHOCTb. B e c b MeXaHM3M PerynMpOBa- KOrO KOpnOpaTUBHOrO I l O ˜ O X O ˜ H O r O
HanOra B
aMepMKaHCKMX HanOrOB.
30%, K rOCypapCrBy CnbrOTHblM ˜anoroa6no-
HMR COAepXMTCR B ˜ ˜ M H C T B ˜ HCTaTbe KO-
HO˜
HOrMe CTpaHbl B C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H HanOrO-
˜IX
AeKCa PK ((0
OHOnaTenbCTBaX T a K X e npMMeHRloT HaJlOraX M A p y M X 0 6 R 3 a ˜ e n b H b l x X e H M e M MOXeT 6 b 1 m OTHeCeHO rOCY˜apCTB0,
IlnaTeXaX B 6 l o p ) ˜ e ˜ ) H a n o r o e b l A KOA˜KC)
((MHOCTpaHHble KOHTPOnMPyeMble () OT B KOTOPOM B3MMaeTCfl ˜ O ˜ O X O H a n o H ˜ I ˜
˜˜r
12.06.2001 r.. H e o l M T a n 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n a ˜ e n b co e a 10% M ˜ e ˜ e e - @ % % 1/3 = 10%).
:
M/ Kopnopaqvlnw B q e n R x n a n o r o o 6 - r
BO M H O M X CTpaHaX ilpHMCHRloTCR
AOXOAOB naHH06I KOMnaHMM M ripe- TPPHC@CPTHOM ˜ ˜ H O O ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ OK B K H M Y I
( ˜ BblWe
˜ KOM-
eHMRaKKyMyJlMpOBaHMR n p ˜ 6 b l B ˜
n 6 b m o yKa3aHO. HaMM H e PaCCMaTPMBaK)T& ˜ M H M P O B ˜ H HKPMTePMM O n p e p e n e H M R
˜I˜
K
MHble, KpOMe HanOrOBblX, B o n p o c b l ) . O @ @ l U ˜ p I i ˜ c n l , npMMepy, B Q ) M H ˜ R H ˜ M V I
HblX l o P M ˜ M K 4 M R X .
T ˜ K cornactio c r a n e 130 Hanorosoro
npas˜na ,
cnepylo˜˜ ˜KOM˜H-
ble s a ˜ o ˜ o ˜ a ˜ e n bOTHOCMT K O@@UJOPH˜IM
crso
O ˜ ˜ ˜ H M 3KOHOMM'ieCKOrO
˜˜UMM
M KOneKCa, eCnM p e 3 M n e H T y I l p M H a A n e X M T DPMCnMKUMRM TOCynaPCTBa, B KOTOPblX
npmo MnM K o c B e H n o 10 M 6onee n p o q e H T o e
cpenm
(03CP), H a n o r o e a R cTaeKa K n p m 6 b l n ˜ e 3 n n e ˜ co-
p ˜a
HMvecrea M P ˜ ˜ B M T H R
npep,noxe-
IX BblqenReTcn K o M n n e K c
BeAeHMlO B HaL(M0HanbHble HanOrO-
eMbl npaBMn, yCTpaHRlo9MX BblrOnbl
(npaewna o
o n b s o e a ˜ ˜ @@uopoe
on
eMblX HHOCTPaHHblX KOMnaHMFIX.
pe3MneHTOB fl0 MHOCTPaHHblM
KMM o n e p a u M R M M T.A.).
3TOM CJlenyeT OTMeTMTb O C O ˜ ˜ H -
3aKnlO'ialo˜yloCR B npMMeHeHMM
MM 73X3nMCIHOrOOp0lUBOKl3HWte-
Ka'ieCTBe OCHOBaHMR PJlR OTHeCeHMR
T ˜ K B Be-
.
OnMpyeMblM KOMnaHMRM.
TIHMM, eCflM ˜ ˜ M T ˜ H C K ˜ M 0 H e p
a K M˜
ee˜
25% K a n w a n a CFC, TO n p M 6 b l n b
H O KOMnaHMM BWIWlaeTCR B H a -
˜
r a e M y t o 6 a 3 y aKqMoHepa. TaKOe x e
MT˜˜˜MH H M M
IlpMMeHReTCR B M˜ ˜
'
TOM B ˜ ˜ H M o M p a 3 y ˜ e e a e ˜ c˜ 6 o

nn
'
Hee 25% KanMTana n ˜ 6 6onee 50%
0

MHnRHfiMM KOHTPOnMPYeMaR MHOC-
MHaR KOMnaHMR PaCCMaTPMBaeTCfi B
oeoA, e c n ˜ e 50% ee
H Menee
˜ K u M p˜ H a m e X M T $MHCKLIM
nM



I
2. H a n o r o e a ˜
rocynapcre C ˜ ˜ ˜ O T ˜anoroo6noxe˜˜e˜. cnym6a
H˜IM PaCCMaTpMBaeT
o n p e a e n r r e ˜ b n ip a s ˜ ˜ e n b c PK. o ˜
˜ ˜e MHOCTpaHHOe rOCyflapCTB0 KaK rOCyflapCT80
c
TO M
aononHeHMe secbMa n o n e 3 ˜ o e n b r o T H b l M H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O O ˜ ˜ O X e c H HMB ˜ M
˜n
1/3
3/4 OT ˜ P M H R T O ˜Q ) M H ˜ R H ˜ M MM K

MeHee , H˜O˜XO.QMMO˜,
T.K. ˜ O A X O AK O n p e A e n e H M o 3 ˜ 0 ciT p a H e c T a e r a H a n o r a H a HMme, q e u
CTpaH C nbrOTHblM H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O O ˜ ˜ O X ˜ H M ˜ M ,
KOTOpblM IlpMMeHfleTCR 3aKOHO,D,aTenbCTBO 0 0nPe.JJenReMaR B COOTBeTCTBMM C HaCTORuMM
Y K ˜ ˜ o M nM
M,
npeg-
˜ 3 n o X e H ˜ b l f il e f i C T B y l o u e f i H O p M e ,
B
KOHTpOnMpyeMblX MHOCTpaHHblX KOMnaHMRX. MMeKITCR 3 a K O H b l 0 KOH@M-
T ˜ KBOO-
,
B o o 6 u e H a n M r M e c n n c K o e , o @ ˜ u ˜ a n b - flOJlaraeT pa3MblTOCTb KpMTepMeB. ,QeHL(ManbHOCTM @ M H ˜ H C O B OMH@Io˜M˜˜MM
˜˜
"1/3
HO y T B e p w a e M b l x r o c y A a p c T B a M M B u e n g x P Y X M B W M C b KPMTePMeM K ˜ ˜ ˜ x C T ˜ H C K OM MH@oPM˜L(MM 0 KOMnaHMRX, KOTOPble
Mn ˜
T o q H o r o O n p e n e n e H M R c r p a H , IOPMQUK˜MM H˜J˜O˜OBO˜
CTaBKM)), OTHOCMTenbHO HeCJlOXHO nO3BOnRloT COXPaHRTb T ˜ ˜ 0 @ ˜ K T M ˜ ˜ C K O M
HY
- pac-
KOTOP˜IXOTHOCRTCR K O@@LUOPH˜IM, e n a n e n b u e M M y u e c T s a MnM ˜ ˜ K T M ˜ ˜ C K
O n p e A e n M T b K p y r COOTBeTCTByKILL(MX CTpaH.
r ˜ McKnloclaeT
o O A H ˜ KC J l e ˜ y l o u MKPMT˜PM˜?, O T O P ˜ I ˜
O Aoxoaa)).
K
n p o c r p a H e H H o e RsneHMe, Ha i snanenbue
M O X e T n p M M e H R T b C R BMeCTO Y K a 3 a H H O r 0 ,
flpaKTMKe C n O p H b l e CMTyaU,MM OTHOCMTenbHO T ˜ K M M 6 p a 3 0 ˜ . M O X H O OTMeTMTb, '-IT0
0
- ((HanMrMe B rocynapcree 3 a ˜ o ˜ o KOH@M-
TOG oe
O@@WO˜HOCTM/ H˜o@@LL!o˜HoCTM MnM Ka3aXCTaHCKOe 3aKOHOaaTenbCTBO M3Ha'ianb-
e c r ˜noaxop, K aaun-
B ˜ J ˜ M K O ˜ P V I T ˜ H K M . AeHL(ManbH0CTM @ M H ˜ H C O B O ˜ H @ O ˜ M ˜ ˜ M MHO n o ˜ p a 3 y ˜ e e a r n ˜i
B M
MHO˜
lopMCAMKU,MM. M no
n p M M e p y , B 3TOM OTHOWeHMM M H T ˜ ˜ ˜ C HM n MI M H @ O ˜ M ˜ ˜ 0 KOMllaHMRX, K O T O p b l e
˜ ˜ MM HMCTpMpOBaHMlo aeRTenbHOCTM pe3MAeHTOB
noflxop, - c y u e c r e y e T T.H. ( ( 6 e n b l i ) ) c n M c o K flO3BOnRloT COXpaHRTb T ˜ ˜ 0 @Y K T M C ˜ ˜ C K O MW p e 3 O @ @ L U O P H ˜ KOMnaHMM, '-IT0 B b l p a X a -
H˜ I˜
( B O T n M q M e OT o ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ c ˜ ˜ o c E n a n e n bH e ˜ uH u Hc T s aI Mx w @ ˜ K T ˜ ˜ C K O n O C b B YCTaHOBneHMM B e C b M a HM3KOrOYpOBHR
T˜˜y Mye˜ M
n
Aoxona)), snanetim
( ( c ˜ ˜ P H ˜ I x M )3aKOHOAaTenbCTBO 0 KOHTPO-
)) , snaaenbue M o x e T nopoaMTb o MB
˜ ˜ ˜ M A ˜ HA T nO M
npoueHTa
n M p y e M b l X KOMnaHMRX PaCnpOCTpaHReTCR H a C n O p H b l e CMTYaL(MM. 6 b l n 0 6 b 1 3 a H M M a T e n b - o @ @ W O ˜ H O K O M f l a H M M , n O C n e KOTOpOrO
˜˜
ecex rocynapcre, tie HO B c n y q a e p a 3 p e w e cnopa e
nonaeluMx B
KoMnannM ˜˜˜ paMKax o @ @ w o p ˜ a aK o M n a H m p a c c M a T p m s a e T c 9
K ˜ nK M -
cyne6˜oro a 3 6 M p a ˜ e n b c ˜ ˜ 6 n l o A a ˜ b .
/I,aHHblfi CIIMCOK. p Haa KaK K O H T p O n M p y e M a R p e 3 M n e H T O M . p
K ˜ ˜ ˜ X C T ˜3aKOHOAaTenbCTBO M M e e T
HCKO˜ KaKMM 0 6 p a 3 0 ˜K ˜ ˜ ˜ x C T ˜ HCC fK6Mf i e ˜ o n -
yl y˜ BOAMnOCb B b l W e , 6 0 MHOrMX C T p a H a x n a H H b l f i
(a0 50%)
yreepX,L(e˜Hblfi n e p e ' 4 e H b o@-
O@M˜M˜˜˜HO P e n e n R T b , H ˜ C K O ˜ ˜ K O ˜ T O L M( H O CTPaHbl
MnM ; ˜ npOueHT BblWe M KOM˜MHMPY˜TC˜
@WOPH˜IX OH ( n o c r a ˜ o ˜ n ep a B ne H M R
n ˜˜ e CTpOrMe 3 a K O H b l O K O H @ M ˜ ˜ ˜ H L & ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜fl0O C T M
H C COBOKyllHblM B n a f l e H M e M pe3MneHTOB A O n H
c ˜ p y r ˜ c r pn H a M M .
ua
H a u v l o H a n b ˜ o r o6 a ˜ P e c n y 6 n ˜ a 3 ˜x -
˜a K˜a cpaeHeHM0 YqaCTMFI B KaflMTaJle O @ @ W O P H O ˜ K O M n a H M l l
npa-
c r a H N? 60 OT 25.02.2003 r. ((06yrsepme- ( ˜ . e . , H a n p M M e P B CWA, AOCTaTOqHO H e
P˜˜BMTM˜
Ka3aXCTaHCKOrO a H a n O r a
06
HMM n e p e r ˜ n O@@WOPH˜IX OH ˜ J R uenei npocro e n a A e t i M e ˜ ˜ ˜ M A ˜ H T Oy c r a s H o r o
10% M
BMn MHOCTpaHHblX K O H T p O n M p Y e M b l X
K a n n T a n a , HO M q ˜ 0 6 b tie M e t i e e 50% ronocy-
Ae-
˜ ˜ H ˜ O B C C T ˜˜ ˜˜X O neRTenbHOCTM,
MK O BO˜˜ KOMnaHMRX M M e e T A S l M T e n b H y K I MCTOPMD C 1
K I u M X ˜ K U n p M H a m e X a n 0 aMepMKaHCKMM

RTenbHOCTM n p ˜ @ e C ˜ M O H a n b H b YqaCTHMKOB
lX HeOAHOKPaTHblMM M3MeHeHMRMM HOpMbl,
perynnpylo˜ei
A ˜ H H B˜ nIp o c .
˜
PblHKa L(eHHblX6yMarMMHblXnMueH3MPYeMblX ˜KUMOH˜˜˜M).
o
6y- P a ˜ e Y ˜ a 3 p e 3 ˜ ˜ PK,˜ M Ma K I U M ˜ 6 0 n e e ˜ O r 0 , B 1996 r O A Y B AaHHYKI CTaTbKI
˜˜
BMAOB neRTenbHOCTM H a P b l H K e UeHHblX e n e
6bma e H e c e H a nonpaelta, c o r n a c H o ˜ o ˜ o p o f i
cuny 3 a ˜ o ˜ ((0˜andrax A p y r M x 0 6 ˜ 3 a -
a,
M a r , ,4eRTenbHOCTM HaKOnMTenbHblX neHCM- M
6lo)˜me˜)> coaepxan ((10
O H H ˜ I X o H ˜ , o B ˜ ) .O A H ˜ K O ˜ n e He He t˜bI ˜
˜p q i
@ Tenbtiblx n n a T e x a x B CnOBa npOueHT06)) 6 b 1 n 3aMeHeHbl
˜
CTaTbKI 39:
Y T B e p W e H B UeJlflX COBeplueHCTBOBaHMfl CnOBOM (('iaCTb)), T.e., MCXOAR M3 6 y ˜ e a n b -
( ( C T ˜ T39. ˜ O X O A ,f l 0 n y q e H ˜ b lB CTpa-
˜R
HopMaTneHoro n p a e o B o r o perynMpoeaHM9 i H O r O nOHMMaHMR H O p M b l , AOCTaTOqHO 6 b 1 n o
Hax c nbroTHblM ˜ a n o r 0 0 6 n o x e ˜ ˜ e ˜ 1%
Ae-
˜ ˜ H K O E I C K M ˜ ˜T ˜ ˜ X O B O ˜
OC fleflTeflbHOCTM, B n a A e H M R Ka3aXCTaHCKMM p e 3 M A e H T O M
1. E c n p e 3 M A e H T y n p M H a m e X M T n p R M 0
˜
RTenbHOCTM n p O @ e C ˜ k l O H a J l b H b l XYqaCTHMKOB YCTaBHOrO @ 0 H n a o @ @ L L I o ˜ H o ˜ ˜
KOMnaHMM,
PblHKa ueHHblX 6
y ˜ aMHblXnMueH3MPyeMblX
r˜ MnM KOCBeHHO 6onee 10 n p O u e H T O B YCTaB- ee K O H T P O ˜ M P Y ˜ M OOA- ˜.
'i˜06bl nPM3HaTb
BMAOB AeRTenbHOCTM H a P b l H K e UeHHblX 6 ˜ - H a K o enocnencrem, EMAMMO, e o 3 0 6 n a g a n
HOT0 @ O H A ˜ MHOCTpaHHOrO KIpM/3,MCleCKOrO
mnu 6onee 10 f l p a r M a ˜ M q ˜ b l ln 0 . 4 ˜ 0 M . o f l p a ˜ K 0 fOT 1999
˜n
M a r , AeflTenbHOCTM HaKOflMTenbHblX neHCMOH- nMua OH M M e e T npoueHToe ? i
H ˜ I @ O H ˜ ˜ OT.e. H a n o r o e b l e O p r a H b l H e Mary
X B, r O n O C y l o u M X ˜ K ˜ 3TOrO IOpMAMqeCKOrO
MG r O n a ((10 npOueHTOB)) 6 b 1 n BHOBb B 0 3 8 p a -
˜
nuua, n0ny.rae-r
K o T o p o e B CBOKI o q e p e a b
M M PyKOBOflCTBOBaTbCR n p M n p M M e H e H M M U e H b l B HOPMY M COXpaHeHbl B / J ˜ L ? c T B Y K I ˜ ˜ ˜
crpatie c n b r o T H b l M ˜anoroo6noxe-
x e0 ˜ 130 Hanoroeoro K o a e K c a .
˜0
HanoroBoro 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n a ˜ e n b c r e a . craTbe
Cornac˜oo c n e a H e u y 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n p o e l cGO flanee PaCCMOTpMM BOnpOC, rlT0 MMeHHO
n ry HMeM, T O r a a 3TOT AOXO.4 MnM 'iaCTb flOXOAa,
smloraerca B nanoroo6naraeub1l oxo on
BHeCeHMM M 3 M e H e ˜ M fM f l ˜ n ˜ n ˜ e H6kHeKO-
i li OTHOCRuaRCFI K p e 3 M n e H T Y , BKnloClaeTCFI B
ero 3 ˜ nonoxeHMe
o
0 6 n a r a e ˜ b l i˜0xo.q.
PK no B O n p O - ˜aaaxc˜anc˜oro pe3n˜enra, sna˜eouero
T O p b l e 3aKOHOflaTenbHble aKTbl
M K o c s e H H o 10 M 6onee n p o u e H T a -
a npmo WI
C a M ˜ a n o r o o 6 n o ˜ e H a˜ r r ˜HanMCaHMR
( ˜ AaTy ˜ npMMeHReTcR T a w e K Y ˜ ˜ C T M K I e 3 ˜ n e B ˜
p ˜
@ o p ˜ ao
x
ApyrMx p r a ˜ ˜ 3 n p e A˜ p˜ H n -
aunM MM O @ @ W O P H O ˜ K o M n a H M M . P e r y n ˜ p o e a ˜ ˜
H a C T o f I u e i CTaTbH 3aKOHOnpOeKT HaXOAMnCR
acnena T a K m e H e o A H o K p a T t i o noneep-
y r n a s b l rocyaapmsa) e K a 3 a x - M a ˜ e n b c ˜ ReRTenbHOCTM, H e o 6 p a 3 y l o q ˜ x
ok 3˜0ro
H a nofinMcM
c r a H e TaKme 6 y n e ˜y u e c r e o e a T b n e p e q e H b apMAMrecKoenMuo.
c r a n O C b M3MeH‚¬'HMRM, O A H a K O OCTaHOEiMMCfl



Ilepeo˜aqanbnanpeAaK4nn narbn 130 Hanorosoro

E c n p e ˜ n e npwiamexm n p m o vlnM K o c s e H H o 10 M 6onee
˜˜y 10 M 6 0 n e e
˜ E c n p e 3 M A e H T y n p M H a m e x M T n p R M 0 MnM KOCBeHHO
˜
n p o u e H T o e y c r a e H o r o K a n M T a n a I O P M A M ˜ ˜ C K On O u a - ˜ e p e w -
˜˜ npoueHToe ycTasHoro K a n m a n a lopManrecKoro n ˜ u a - ˜ e p e 3 ˜ f i e ˜ ˜
Mncl OH M M e e T 10 ˜ 6 o n e ep o u e H T o e ronocylounx a
A e H T a MnM OH MMeeT 10 M 6onee n p O u e H T O B r O n O C y K I u M X a˜ukli n ˜ u v l3i ˜ o r o
nony-
3 ˜ 0 r o o p M n M q e c K o r o n M u a - ˜ e p e 3 ˜ a e K o Ta p o e B ceolo o q e p e n b I o p M A M r e c K o r o n ˜ u a - ˜ e p e 3 ˜ a K o T˜ p o,e B CBOD o q e p e n b
e ˜ oa
i ˜ ˜ o,
rocyaapcree c n b r o T H b l M H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O O ˜ ˜ O XT˜ rH a
n o n y v a e T noxop. B rocyaapcree c n b r o T H b l M H ˜ ˜ O ˜ O O ˜ ˜ O X ˜ H rM e TM o x o n B
a˜ a, o AM ˜M,
˜ o r n a rlacrb poxona lopvlanrlec˜oro racrb wn6bmfl l o p n ˜ n r e c ˜ o nnqa, o˜nocnuanca pe3n-
ro
wa nnqa, ornocauaaca K K
aenry, BKnloqaeTcR B ero ˜ a n o r 0 0 6 n a r a e ˜ b ˜ i0 x 0 . ˜ .
p e ˜ ˜ e ˜ r n l , r a e ˜ ero ˜ a n 0 r 0 0 6 n a r a e ˜ b l˜ o x o a .
e˜ y o Bc˜ 1
i




. 1
Nnl 2005
K a K u M o H e p a M B UenRx p a c v e T a nanoroo6na-
raeworo noxona n p o n o p u m o H a n b H o g o n M MX no c r a s b e 130 Hano
a) flpM6blflb O@@UIOPHO˜ ICW?k%naHMMr .
y'iamnfl B y c r a B H o M KanMTane o c t ) @ ˜ o p ˜ o R
&
noxop,, 0 6 p a 3 0 B a ˜ ˜ b l l ; ( nacne
T.e. CIMCT˜IR
˜ o x o ˜O .˜ H ˜pKHO e c y u e m B o -
" KOMnaHMM B e n b , KaK yKa3blBanOCb B b l U e ,
ae
eHMe, 'iTO pe3MneHTy H ˜ O ˜ X O ˜ J M M O Q o p ˜ a n b ˜ o p a c n p e n e n e H H a R n p M 6 b l n b
He BbHeTOB PaCXOAOB;
CBOR ˜ a n o r 0 0 6 n a r a e ˜ b 1 h 06paso˜ e 6) 'iacrb n p ˜ 6 b m n p, o n o p u ˜ o ˜ a n b n o A
HMKaKMM H M O X e T OTHOCMTbCR K
sKnloraTb B ˜
nonw yLtacrHn p e 3 ˜ n e ˜ ˜ a .
nony'ia- aK&MoHepaM.
C O B O K Y ˜ H˜ O ˜ ˜ B O ˜ ˜ O X O A ,
˜I AO
8 u e n f l x yToqHeHlrtR n a H H o r o B o n p o c a A0 Cornac˜o r a r b m 79 80 Hanoro˜oro
c M
noxon ˜ a 3 a x -
c ( K M r - K o ˜ c a n ˜ ˜ ˜ r ) )q a n o c b csanpoco˜
a ˜ n i o . r a l o q ˜ece p a c x o n b l .
A Ko.qeKca B ˜ a n 0 r 0 0 6 n a r a e ˜ b l f i
06pa
B Hanoro˜blh
KOMMTeT M M H H H C T ˜ ˜ C T B ˜
@M- CTaHCKMX pe3MfieHTOB BKJlK)'iaK)TCRnMBMAeH-
rnacHo 0 6 q e n p ˜ ˜ f i 3KOHOMMWC-
˜o˜y
PK, H a qT0 ˜ ˜ O ˜ H O M O W ? H H p rIa˜H˜ n b ˜ BTOM wcne nonyqeHHbleo˜MHorrpaHHblx
QHMMaHMK) n p M 6 b l n b OnpeAenReTCR HaHCOB O˜ ,
OTBeTMn, TO ((HanoronnaTenblC(MK, CooTBeTc- OPMAM'ieCKMX nMU.
130 HanOrOBOrO flop, nMBM,QeHp,aMM COrnaCHO CTaTbe 10
˜ByK)ll.lMk YUlOBMRM CTaTbM
B C O B O K Y ˜ Hr0-˜ ˜ Hanoroeoro KOneKCa n0HMMaloTCR:
˜I
KOaeKCa, o 6 ˜ 3 BKJllo'iMTb

go˜oci
noxop,'iamb a ) goxoa, nonnemaqvfi no
n p ˜ 6 b l K)pvl,qMrecKoro
n˜ BblnnaTe
n ˜ u ; a - ˜ e p e 3 m ˜ e n p˜ al , n R e ˜ o R MCXOAR
o ˜ ef e OKUWRM;
y'iacrm
143 O o n M p e 3 ˜ n e B y c aa e H o M Ka-
˜˜r 6 ) 'iaCTb '4MCTOrO AOXOAa, P a C n p e n e -
ero
nvl-rane y ˜ a 3 a ˜ ˜ ˜o p e 3 w n e n ˜ a ) ) .
er o n n e M o r o npMnMqecKMM nMUoM M e m y
˜ P PaCCMOTPeHMM BblWeYnOMRHYTOrO
M y'iacrtiMKahnM.
B naHHOM
3aKOHOflPOeKTa 0 BHeCeHVlM M ˜ M ˜ H ˜ H M ˜ KJK˜IO-˜M˜O
M Cfly'iae MHYO
˜ o ˜ o J ˜ H ˜BH u ˜ ˜
HeKOTOPble 3aKOHOnaTenbHble MHTepnpeTagMo nMeMnehlp,o? HanpMMep, q
no B o n p o c a M ˜ a n o r o o 6 n o x e ˜ ˜ cMny HtoaHcoe 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n a ˜ e n b c O@@WOP-
˜
B
PK rea
pa6oreR r p y n n b l o 6 p a q a n o c b BHM- HOR IOPHCAMKUMM, MOXHO H e npMHMMaTb BO
paMKax
C O ˜ ˜ ˜ CpH -
n MO
MaHMe Ha n a H H b l f i BOnpOC. BHMMaHMe, T.K., 00-IlepBblX, OaHHOe nOHMMa-
HRTOR PenaKuMM - 0 6 q e n p ˜ ˜ ˜ BO-BTOP˜IX, npono-
˜oe.
3aKOHOnpOeKTa n p ˜ 6 b l n b HMe
H a n p o m˜ a s a x ˜ ˜ Ha n o rc e˜ l ˜ oe r a H b l
a˜ o be p
u c x o a ˜ aonn yracTua
n3
onpenenReTcR
!TQ e non n p ˜ 6 b l n b m
cnenye˜OHM- p e 3 c l ˜ e ˜ ˜ cTasHoM KanMTane nHocT-
B ya ˜ ˜ A ˜ T T ˜ ˜ K T O B ˜ T MMeHHO B TOM
aMBMneHnbl ˜
m
H˜˜O˜OBOM
El% nOXOn 3 a MMHYCOM Bbl'ieTOB P˜HHO˜
KOMnaHMM, T.e. flOnpa3yMeBaeTCR IlOHMMaHMM, KaK 3T0 YKa3aHO B
('iMCTblfi
m). I ˜ M ˜ H ˜BH rM n e 130 Hanorosoro
c a˜
V npWlOpL&4OHaJlbHOffb AOnM YYaCTMR. KOAeKCe.
Aanee, OTTonKHyBulMcb O T a H a n m a ˜ 3 ˜ e - T ˜ K M M6 p a 3 0 ˜ , JJMBMAeHAbl P a C n p e -
W K c a cnoea ((noxo,n,))Ha ((npn6blnb)), nona- 0
H˜HMR craTbM 1 3 0 Hanoro˜oro o n e s c a , KO-
h HOCHT ˜ T O ' ˜ H R K ) xapaKTep
, K AenRDTCR M e m y aKQMOHepaMM TOnbKO M3
˜M˜ M lnMeeT
T o p b l e B o n p e ˜ e n e ˜M eo e c n o c o 6 ˜ ˜ ˜ y l LILICTOrOnOXOna ( n p ˜ 6 b 1 n M B COOTBeTCrBMM
˜ pi o˜
TO B Han0r006naraeMblfi
mblo ycracloemb, ˜)
Ilpa˜TM'iec˜ofi
peanM3auMM n a H H 0 f i HOpMbl,
˜ a 3 a x c ˜ a ˜ c p e 3 o ˜ e B K na -
˜or m ˜˜o C MX AOnRMM Y'iaCMR.
6onee TO eCTb AMBHneHflbl-
6b1O Xe,
XOTenOCb BHMMaHMe Ha
ETCR TOnbKO ' i ˜ ˜ ˜ bfiOXOP, O@$UIOPHO˜
lfi 3T0 OAHO M TO
˜P˜TMT˜
s ˜ n o ' i a o q ˜ee
R m 0 6 a n b H b l e BOflpOCbl, KOTOPble BO3HMKaOT 'iTO M n p M 6 b l n b 0@@UI0pH0fi KOMnaHMM, T.e.
IbanaHvln, H e pacxoabl,
p pa6o˜e H ˜ G .
c
NI urenyer O T M ˜ T M T ˜TO o @ ˜ u ˜ a n b ˜ o r n ˜ yxe pacnpene-
x e c y M M a AeHer,
F Ta TonbKo
, o
no AaH- 130
I / ˜ C X OM3R
˜ CMblCna neHHaR M e m y a K u M o t i e p a M u M l o p n n w i e c K M
WRCHeHMR B H ˜ C T O R U ( M ˜
MOMeHT HOPMbl CTaTbM
n0HRTb ee
My 8OnpOCy n p M H a m e x a q a f l MM. K o ˜ e q n o Ha npaKTMKe
,
H a n o r O B o r o KOfleKCa, HeCnOXHO
HeT.
K p o ˜ TOrO, BO3HMKaeT BOnpOC 0 TOM,
e - MCKJlDqMTb B03MOXHOCTb 3aKOHHOrO
Uenb AaHHaR n p n 6 b l n b M O K e T 6blTb M H e PaCnpe-
p




WK, XOTR @ ˜ K T H ' ˜ ˜ C K M
&?neHa, M MOXeT npMHa-
M36eXaHMR OT y n n a n l K ˜ ˜ ˜ X C T ˜ H CH aM o r o s
K nX
MMeHHO n p ˜ 6 b l n b( L I M C T ˜ I˜ ˜ x 0 ˜ )
˜0
no- A n e X a T b aKUMoHepaM.
M y e T slcnloqa-rb B ˜ a n o r o o 6 n a r a e ˜ b l k n y r e M aKKyMynMpOBaHMR n p ˜ 6 b l n H a c l e T a X
u
C T ˜ T 130 Hanoro˜oro tianpas-
@ p e w n e ˜ ˜ 7.e. YTO n o f i p a 3 y ˜ e s a t bnon O@@UOPH˜IX K O M ˜ B H M ˜ ˜ .
AOCTMraeTcR 3TO ˜R KoneKca
a,
cny'iaw,
npOCTblM C ˜ O C O ˜ O M p n 6 b m b O @ @ U O ˜ H O ˜ ˜ n e H a MMeHHo Ha T e
n: K o r A a aKQMoHep
@W˜HOMU'iaCTb n p ˜ 6 b l n OTHOCRulaflCR
˜,
KOMnaHMM ( n p M YCIlOBMM, 'iTOOHa npM3HaeTCR o @ @ u r o p ˜ o RKOMnaHMM, X e n a R M 3 6 e x a ˜ b
pHnCHTY)). B e n b lopM.4M'ieCKM n p M 6 b l n b
Ka3aXffaHCKMM pe3MAeH- K ˜ ˜ ˜ X C T ˜ H C H aM o r o e , H e a @ ˜ w ˜ p y e ˜
K nX
KOHT˜O˜M˜˜˜MO˜˜
bl$)UIopH˜i KOMnaHMM H e MOXeTOTHOCMTbCR
- 10% y'iacrMR M 6onee) aeTouaTclrecKM
p w a p ˜ l e x a ˜ ero a˜uno˜epy/ n p M 6 b l n b B BMAe nMBMneHnOB HanOrOBblM
TOM
b) Y'iaCTHHKy
6 y n e ˜ ˜ ˜ n o ' i a eB˜˜ c n o r 0 0 6 n a r a e ˜ b 1#oxon

ignee B h O p r a H a M M aKKYMYnMpYeT H a O@$UIOPHO˜
UenRX OflTblMH3aUMM TeKCTa
K ˜ ˜ ˜ X C T ˜HHnC rK M ˜
KOMnaHMH. a O M MOrYT
pe314nenTa BHe 3aBMCMMOcT11 OT TOTO, 6 b l n ˜
iROnb3OBaTbCR TePMMH (˜˜KuHoH˜P))),nOKa
r tie 6 y f l e ˜p a c n p e A e n e H a
a n M nauepeHMsl n e p e n a s a r b 3 ˜ n p ˜ 6 b l n b
y 6 b l T b n p M M e H e H b l TOnbKO n p M nORBneHMM
M e w y HHMM
none 3
pe- OPMC-
neHer B p e ˜ ma 3 a x c r a ˜ c ˜ o R
˜˜
a K w o H e p a M , x p a H n T b Ha n e n o 3 ˜ Mnvl
˜e
wetiMeM ynonnoMo'ieHHoro opraHa o@-
- 3 T 0 MOXeT 6blTb B U l Y Y a e MX nepe-
&l0ptiokKOMnaHMM. M e m y T ˜ CTaTbR130 AMKuMM
MHBeCTMpOBaTb B ˜ a ˜ M e - n M 6 6 b e ˜ T b l .
00
M
H ˜ C M O T P R IlPOCTOTY
u r o r o B o r 0 KOAeKCa ˜ p e 6 y e ˜ Ha M CnpaBen- BOAa B BMAe AMBMaeHaOB Ka3aXCTaHCKOMY
BKnlo'ieHMR B
n u e o c T b n a H H o r o M ˜ X ˜ H H cnenyer
m o r o o 6 n a r a e ˜ b 1 f˜ 0 x MMeHHO c a ˜ o R ˜M˜, pe3˜ne˜˜y.

i
T ˜ K H M 6 p a 3 0 ˜ , eCnM
0 K ˜ ˜ ˜ X C T ˜ H C AMKqMM B n a A e n b u a O @ @ U O ˜ H O KOMnaHMM,
KH˜ ˜˜ OT O @ @ U I O ˜ H ˜ I XK O M ˜ ˜ B H M ˜ , ˜ E I T C K M ˜ ˜
eCnM
25%
T.K. B M T O R flOny'4eHHafl n p ˜ 6 b l n b , o x p a -
C
pe3MneHT PeUIMT nOny'iMTb aMBMaeH&bl OT aKqMoHep BnaneeT H e MeHee a˜qMk
B
TereHue, MMHMMYM,ontior0 rona.
HeHHaH 3 a c r e T n e r a n b H b l x c x e M H a n o r o s o r o
o @ @ u o p ˜ o kK o M n a H M M , TO H a n o r o e b l k
o6narae˜cfl n p a e M n a M o
no T ˜ K M M6 p a 3 o ˜ ,nonaraew
nep˜yto r e p e a b 06narae.r n p M - nnaHMpoeaHMa, o BecbMa
KoAeKc B o
6 b l n b o @ @ L U O ˜ H O KOMnaHMM, a 3aTeM 3TY KOHTPOnMPYeMblX MHOCTpaHHblX KOMnaHMflX Cepbe3HblM 0 6 p a ˜ M ˜BHMMaHMe H a OTKpbl-
b
˜
cnyrae C r a T b n 130 Hanoroeoro
x e C ˜ M M p a c n p e ˜ e n e ˜ ˜B r o n e AMEM-
y BM (B H a w e M
˜, ˜ b l BOnpOC, ˜ o C T ˜ B ˜ ˜ H H M ˜
h Ka3aXCTaHCKHM
˜one˜ca). HanOrOBblM 3aKOHOAaTellbCTBOM 6 OTHOUIC-
AeHnOB; T e M CaMblM B03HMKaeT CMTYaC(Mfl,
˜anoroo6no- HMM OAHOBPeMeHHOrO ˜anoroo6noxe˜mfl
n p o T M e o p e r a u a R n p M H y M n a M ˜anoroo6- B TOM cnyrae ˜ B O ˜ H O ˜
n O X e H H f l , M 3 n O X e H H b l M B CTaTbflX 6 M 7 x e w e ( K ˜ K 1 e p e n p n 6 b l n b o @ @ u o p ˜ o i ˜ M n p ˜ 6 b l o @ @ u o p ˜ o AKOMnaHMM (CITQ
˜ 3 n˜
Hanoroeoro KoneKca, - o n p e A e n e H H o c r M M c a M o no ce6e cnpaee˜nweo),M ˜ M B M ˜ ˜ H
K o M n a n w , TaK M r e p e 3 p a c n p e A e n q e M b l e -
AMBMneHAbl) 6yne˜ gee, n o n y r a e u b l x ˜3 a a ˜ ˜ n pk˜ 6 b 1 n B .
o
Cepbe3HblM HanOrOBblM ˜
cnpasewMBocTH.
6 p e ˜ e H TOnbKO wfl CO3HaTenbHblX M 3 a -
K ˜ o M ˜ H a npaKTMKe GIeAOBaHMe npoTWBHoM cnyae e c r b onacewe, r T o namn
TOrO, e˜
130 Hanoroeoro KoAeKca H e 6 y n e ˜ pa60˜am
H o p M a M cra˜ek M 130 HanOrOBOrO K o n e K c a
80 K o H o n o c n y l u H b l x s n a n e n b u e e O@@UIOPH˜IX
˜oo6ure. TO npMBeAeT K H a M x y n w e M y
˜PMBOAMT ˜ e x ˜ n c l e c npo6ne˜e:
K K O M ˜ ˜ H M C T a.n b ˜ b l e ,eCJlM OHM CTpeMflTCfl
O˜˜
˜ok
xena-
C K P ˜ I TCBOM ˜ o x o , ˜n˜ M,6 o n b t u o ˜
pI CTaTyCa - UAeKlla-
YclMTblBafl ˜ p e 6 0 s a ˜ ˜ e 130 Ha-
CTaTbM ˜ 3aKOHa @ Y H K ˜ M O H ˜ J I ˜ H O ˜ O
noroeoro KoneKca, p e 3 ˜ ˜n e a ˜ ˜e - b u ˜ , HMM M O T W e J l a T b 3TO. Ha ˜ a ˜ ˜MOMeHT
n˜ n blk PaTHBHOCTM)>.
c o c r a s n q n ˜eiaiapau˜ro K o p n o p a T n s H o M y
no CyqeCTByeT AOCTaTOrHOe KOnM'ieCTBO CXeM f l p M PaCCMOTpeHMM BblWeynOMflHYTOrO
csoci ˜ anorod nara e˜b˜k CHM3MTb PMCK 0 6 H a p y ˜ e H M fa ˜ M n M M p 0 B a ˜ - 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n p o e ˜ @ e p e ˜anoroo6norne˜˜fl
l
Hanory, e i c n r o q a e T ˜ Bc˜a
˜ ˜ ˜ H H ˜ I R B Oo˜ P H M a n a B p a M K a x pa6o-
p o x o n racla n p ˜ 6 b IopMnMClecKorOnMua- n nH O C
HOCTM O @ @ U I O ˜ H O KOMnaHMM C MCTMHHblMM
˜˜

˜ e p e ˜ ˜ oTnocauylocR K p e 3 ˜ ˜ e ˜ ˜ y .
e˜˜a, reci r p y n n b l M a x M n M c a f l a p n a ˜ e ˜ ˜ a
PK.
BnaAeflbuaMM (UOB˜ ((KOCBeHHOe BnWeHMe))
MOryT M H e n 0 ˜ 0 q b ) , a TaKXe rPaMOTH0 flp˜ TOM npeAnarancn A o e T a T o r H o
nponopqMoHanbHop.onMsnaAeHw=i;
CnnaHMpOBaTb AOXOAHylO M PaCXOAHytO CIaCTM
OAHOBpeMeHHO pe3MneHT. O T p a X a f l npOCT0k MeXaHM3M, n0380nflloU(Mk YCTpaHblTb
c r a n e 80 Hanorosoro K o A e K c a
cornacHo o @ @ u o p ˜ o i KOMnaHMM.
i OflaCeHMfl 0 ˜@@cKTMBHOCTI.(
O˜OCHOB˜HH˜I˜
B A e K n a p a q M M no KOpnOpaTMBHOMy nOfl0- 130 Hanoro˜oro KOAeKCa, a MMeHHO
KOMneTeHTHble aMepMKaHCKMe CTaTbM
AOnOnHMTb CTaTbH) 91 Hanoro˜oro
XOAHOMY H a n O q B CTpOKe a C 0 ˜ 0 ˜ y i l H b l R OpraHbl BnaCTM n p M MX TeXHMCleCKMX B 0 3 M O X - KOAeKCa
˜oxo,˜)) nOQnyHKTOM 1-1:
ro˜oeok HOCTRX, aBTOpMTeTe C p e n M M Xy a OHX e JH p J b
l ll
AueMneHAbl, n o n y r e H H b l e
3 a npenenaMM P e c n y 6 n ˜ ˜ s a x c ˜ a ˜
Ka˜ ( ( C T ˜ T91. K O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T M ˜ O B K ˜
˜R
o p r a ˜ ˜ 3 a M c Mk e B O ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ C T B A p Rr M e
u˜ n Ha M y
OT COBOKynHOrO
r o n o B o r o aoxona
rocynapcrea, H a n M r w M H o x e c r e a M e m r o -
qxinMqecKoron˜u,a-˜epg3˜ne˜˜a, BiairoraeT
MX nocne c o o ˜ s e ˜ t T ˜ y r o ˜ B ˜ a n o - ˜ ˜ c y n a p ˜r e e˜ H b f x c o r n a u e ˜ o ˜ 3 a w ˜ o n e k c -
˜k
(Hx˜ i˜ec oH 1. Aoxona
M3 CoBoKynHoro r o A o B o r o
TBMH, BblCOKOM Y P O B H e COTPYP.HM'ieCTBa
roo6narae˜bl˜ 0 x 0 ˜ .
k H a n o r o n n a T e n b q M K o e n o v e x a T vlcltnlore-
6 y x r a n ˜ e p c ˜ o ˜ H a c e n e H M s c enacrnw (npoue r o s o p g , ao˜oc HMO:
C O O T B ˜ T C T B ˜ H H OB
, M
H a n o r o B o M y r e T e BOSHMK˜IOTOAHM M re x e H a K o n n e r y / c o c e ˜ a j ,x e r r ˜ o k y n e 6 ˜ o -
c 1-1) anennetinbl, nonyreHnble OT
C ˜ M M ˜ I T p a x a e M b l e B c r p o K a x c(Hanoroo6- lopnnnrecKoro nn˜a-nepe3uraen˜a n3
Z I ˜ M M H M C T ˜ ˜ T M B CMCTeMe H e B C e r n a
HO˜
O,
n a r a e ˜ b noxo,˜)). ˜ @ @ ˜ K T M B Hpa60˜aro˜ WCrU npn6bmn, BKJllore˜˜oAHaJlOrO-
O C TaKMMM CnyclaflMM,
˜h B
dnaraeub˜k aoxop,pe3mnewra, cornacno
Mt.1 xoTenM 6 b 1 ˜ a wO ˜ ˜ Q M HacKonb- L1TO Xe rOBOPMTb 0 K ˜ ˜ ˜ x C T ˜ H CMCTeMe
e T˜, CKO˜
crane 130 nacronuero Koae˜ca*.
KO ˜ e n e c 0 0 6 p a 3 ˜M n o r ˜ r ˜ 0 0 6 n a r a&˜&b x - KOHTPOIIfl.
0 a
B TOM c n y q a e O A H O ˜ H ˜ ˜petuaercs
O ˜ H Y ˜y x @ CYMMY, e c n M u e n b craTbM
M n o n y r a e T c n , CITO cMiyaL(kifl, K o r A a 3 a ˜ o - HO
eonpoc 06 McKnroreHMM neok˜oro a n o r o -
130 Hanoroeoro Konetcca AocTMraeTcfl yxe HOnaTenbCKiO r e T K O H e Per'jnllpyeT BOnpOC H
˜epacnpe˜ene˜nok 0 6 R 3 a ˜ e n b H 0 C T M˜ a n o r o o 6 n o x e ˜ ˜-f l 0 6 n o x e ˜ ˜ f lO c r a e T c g T o n b K o ˜anoroo6-
06
H a c r a n M M 06noxe˜mfl AH M
n p ˜ 6 b l (˜.e. p ˜ 6 b l n naxonflqehcn e q e BMAeHAoe, n o n y r e H H b l x ˜3 yxe O ˜ J I O X ˜ H H O ˜ nomewe n p ˜ 6 b t o @ @ w o p ˜ o kK o u n a H M n
n˜ n ˜, n˜
- r n a e H a f l u e n b cTaTbol 130 Hanoroeoro
H a n o r a w n p w 6 b m ˜M o x e T c n o c o 6 c r e o e a ˜ b
.
BO BnaAeHMM o @ @ ˜ u o p ˜ o R M ˜ ˜ ˜ H M M ) .
KO
˜OM˜-
B 3 ˜ 0 kC B R ˜ M O ˜ ˜ ˜ T H @ @ ˜ K T Y HeBO3BpaTy KanM-
nonaraehn, . O HOPM˜I3 8 -
I
T KOAeKCa.
Tana, n p o K p y r e H n o r o e M e x n y H a p o n H b l x K c o x a n e ˜ ˜ M M e e w H e M e c T o npe-
o,
KOHOnaTenbCTBa n O n X H b l COOTBeTCTBOBaTb
onepaqbiflx, B K a z a x c ˜ a n To e c T b snaneneu ˜ y 6 e w e ˜ ˜ O lT M B ˜˜f ecero, r ˜ co s s a ˜ o
s c
COB˜˜M˜HHO˜ CMTyaL(MM, ˜ i a i a ˜ b l B a I O ˜ e k ˜ f l .
n ˜ 6 0 o o 6 u l el p e K p a T M T M C n O n b 3 0 B a T b
B cwpe p e r y n M p y e M b l x O T H O W ˜ H M ˜ ˜ . ˜ TepMMHOM ˜O@@LUOP)), n O M e w a n M pa6oreA
I
K ˜ 6K m o e b l w e ˜ 3 n o r n e ˜ 0cy4ecreye-r rpynne B H M K H Y T ˜B C Y T ˜n p e A n o x e H H b l x
0 @ @ ˜ 0 p ˜ b KOMflaHMM B CBOMX CXeMaX,
le
b ,
n ˜ 6 0y a e ˜
6 p e ˜ o ˜ e ˜ a a n p˜oka,˜ a n ˜ 3 ˜ p o s a 3@-
u
nbJTaTbCfl CKpblBaTb MCTMHHble MX ˜ b
˜ O C T ˜ T O ˜ H n M e p o B , K o r a a s n a n e n b q b l o@-
np O
AOXOAbl O@@UIOPHO˜ KOMllaHMM. Y ˜ M ˜ b l B a f l @KT mfl3KOHOMMKM rOCyAapCTBa, a T a K X e
@UOPH˜IX K O M ˜ ˜ H M ! H e CTpeMFlTCR V a M B a T b
?
nOXOnbl CBOMX KOMIIBHM˜, T.K. 3TO - rapaHTMfl c
C y U ( e C T B y 0 ˜ M eA 0 CMX n O p aKTyanbH0CTb B C B R ˜ M r e M ˜ T Mn p e N o x e H m H e 6 b l n M
6 e 3 0 n a ˜ H 0 ˜ ˜ i - 1 e r o p e c n e ˜ ˜ a 6 e n b ˜ M r o M n p M B n e K a T e n b H 0 C T b O @ @ W O ˜ H ˜ I XCXeM,
Bc o PaCCMOTpeH bl.
ycrokr˜eoro ˜ 3 ˜ e c nOTOMy c(T0 B nro60˜ onaceme, CITO c 0 6 n a 3 ˜a K u M o H e p a C
ecTb
6 a, y r e T o M ˜ 3 n o x e ˜ ˜ xoo T e n o c b 6 b 1
ro
TonKtieT ero KO BTOPOM˜ny-rcl, n p M TOM B
cnyrae B c e r A a e c r b 6 o n b u o k PMCK o6˜apo- o 6 p a ˜ B H˜ M a H M e 3 a K o ˜ o n a ˜ e a ˜
˜ Mb Hn
nepeyro o q e p e n b n o c T p a n a e T ˜ K O H O M M K ˜
nOBaHMfl 3TOrO HeflpMflTHOrO @aKTa B CMny CYU(eCTByloU(Me BOnpOCbl P e r y n M p O B a H M R
˜ a n o r o o 6 n o x e ˜ ˜˜ 6 b m b 1 , nonyrae˜ok
np fl
K a 3 a x c r a ˜ a H e n o n y r M s w a f l ,qononHMTenb-
,
aKTMBHblX ˜ e p 0 I l p M R ˜ M h M n e T e H T H b l X
KO
KaMXCl'aHCKMMM pe3MaeHTaMM OT o@@*-
npyrkle
OpraHOB M/MnM PaCKPblTMR M H C ˜B ˜ C T ˜ ˜ ˜3,, a 6 0 ˜ ˜ C K O ˜
HblX U H ˜ M L ˜ I a p ˜ a r o ˜
HO
rocy.qapcrsa, M M e l o q M e 6onee r ˜ 6 ˜ 3 a -e HblX K O M ˜ ˜ H M YCIeTOM p e a n M k ˜ E j > i ( ˜ ˜ -
o C˜,
M H @ O ˜ M ˜ ˜M T.A.
MM
a
˜PM KOHOAaTenbCTBO. H a p o n H o r o o @ @ u o p ˜ o r o ˜ 3 ˜ e c a ,T a m e
6
TOM o@@LUOPH˜R KOMnaHMfl npMMe-
KCT˜TM,U l e a y e T OTMeTMTb, CITO, K n p M M e - IlpaKTMKM per)'JlMpOBaHMfl AaHHOrO BOnpOCa
HfleTCfl B UenRX MMHMMM3aqMM YPOBHFl H a n o -
B e A y u M X M M ˜ O B ˜ crpaii e n e p B y r o o.cepeAb
onepauklk, IX
py&IHMfl, HMeK)U(afl C O ˜ C T B ˜ HnH a BIM n a 0
p˜ ˜
˜ O O ˜ ˜ O X ˜ MeWyHapOAHblX
HMR
B UenflX 3aU(MTbI MHTepeCOB rOCynapCTBa M
KOHTpOnMpyeMblX MHOCTPaHHblX KOMnaHMRX,
OflHaKO 3T0 HMKaK H e OTpaXaeTCR H a IlOTepflX
˜ a s a x c r a ˜ c ˜n pxe n n p ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ a ˜ e n e k
o c s 0 6 o x ˜ a e ˜ B M A ˜ H A ˜ In,o n y q e H H M e
6 1 0 ˜ x e CTpaHbl
˜a AM vl
rocyAapcreenHoro top˜c-