reopra npasa
t

1M 2 C . 117 n<
P.A. M ˜ M ˜ T O B ˜ Uleaylo˜Me
BblnWlReT OTnU- TOnKOBaHMfl MIlpHMeHeHMR n.n. T
npeanoxenMM n. 2
B noulaHeM
YMTenbHbte YepTbl HWBMXMMOrO MMyqeCrsa 3a˜nmae˜a
Ecnm 6yKBanbHoe TOnKOBaHMe
HMOCTM, He&BMXMMOrO 3˜0b
CTaTbM.
O ABMXMMOrO:
T
M˜yqeCTsa˜) o 6ue˜ 1) IlpMKpeflneHHOCTb K3Wne; 'l, KaK yxe 6
fl. b CWaHO BblLUe, no3eonae˜
˜
B BMAe 3 a ˜ p e n n e ˜ a
B
n. 1cr. 1 7 rpamaHcitoro KoaeKca Pecny6n˜ia rosopmb 0 6 MaepnbtBatoqeM nepewie ne-
1 2) CffeL(ManbHb1e 3aKOHOaaTenbHble TPe-
aemmioro mtyuecrea, a nepeoe npeg,noxe-
(aanee - TK). K HeAmwMMocrM K PertlcTpaUMM W O K C HenBMXM-
˜OB˜HMR
Ka3axcra˜
H e n. 20
MoCTbK); M np44pa8HMBaHMM K HWBMXMMOCM
OTHeCeHbl: 3eMenbHble y'4aCTKM, 3aaHMR, C -
O
3)
opyxeHus, MnoronemMe nacameiim M woe ABM)KMM˜IX no npwpoae seqet?, TO c ˜ b l c n
B 3 M H B H e npaBa CO˜˜TB˜HHOCTM
OH K O e M
npowo eTopro npep,nameHmn n. ZCT. 1 7He nomaem
˜ ˜ y ˜ e m i o , cesl3a˜noe 3e˜nefi, e.
c 1
T. ( f l p 0 ˜ 3 ˜ 0 BeqHblX f l p a ˜ ) a HenBMXM-
˜˜bl˜ H
norMlrecKoMy O ˜ ˜ R C H ˜ H M M. ˜nonaraehn,
I
nepewqeHvle KOTOP˜IX6e3 ˜ecopaa- M m b C MOMeHTa perMCTpaUMM8 YCTaHOWleH- D
06be˜˜b1,
˜ep1ioroywep6a na3naren˜o YTa W O np2iBllnbHWTOnKOBaHMe MKJllo'4aeTcR
HOM 3a˜onopa˜enbcrse
nopmice;
MX H˜BO˜MOXHO.
4) coxpanenfies a ˜ o Mecra HaxoxqeHm
˜a
6yKBanbH0e TOnKOBaHMe 3TOKl flOnOXeHMR B T M '4TO 3aKOHOAaTenbClBOM MOWT 6 b l ˜ b
O,
npM M3MeHeHMW llqX94Wbm-
˜OnHt+lWJlbHOO˜pe#Jlt34
MKOHa n03BOnR@TYTBepwaTb, C O flepWeHb
T
l HeaBMXMMOrO MMyUeCTBa
Mecra x m e n b m a ero o6na,qa˜en˜˜.
xa- X H ˜ b l X ˜ e u l tKOTOpble IlpMpaBHHBaIOTCIl
H ˜ B M X M M ˜MhneeT ˜olepnb˜ealoqnR !˜,
˜˜M
B ˜ I C K ˜ ˜ ˜ H H O ˜ ˜ T O ' ˜ K ˜ ˜ MHB- M R H ˜ ˜ M M M , ˜ .
K
palcrep. 3a˜onoaa˜enb p Qop˜ynvlpoeaHw
n ˜ C03B)NHO ˜ ˜ H
M M.r. M ˜ c ˜ B M ' ˜ ,
KOHKP˜TH˜IA H eK ) . ˜ . % ˜ H K o B ˜
M KOTOpble
3˜0ro
npaswla ˜cnonbsoeanHe 3 m b BaXHO R O O M bpa3nM'4MeM e w y
PBAT
weAM
M fl0˜p06HblR l e p e H b ('4˜0
f nposcraBnReTcR O˜˜FICHSIOT
BblaeneHMe HenBMXMMOCTM M3 llOHST!AeMC&˜TEHHO HeABWMblX
M M ˜ I M ) , npaemo,
T ˜ Y ˜ H O B ˜ I ˜ O ˜ H a 3a˜penwn OCTanbHOro MMyU@CTBa
BaXHOCTbIOWfl3KO- 8eqeG, Ha KOTopble B O ˜ ˜ ˜ C I ˜ J W H H O ˜
GeneHM
npMponHblX p@-
cnenyn KOTOPOMY H M K WaHbl MMeIO˜MXCR
O MM pacnpompaHmcg npaeoeoGt WXMM H ˜ B M -
MOXHO Ha npamMKe 6e3
cypCOB, Te˜trofiB 1M apyrofi HeABHMMOCTktC
0˜06blx3aTpya˜eHMROnpeAenMTb HeABMXM- C F3 XMMOrO MMyUeCTBa, H KQTOPble TaKOBblMM
O
no cyqemy He R ˜ n n l o mfloa06˜blRnomoa
3eMenbHblMM YaCTKaMM, aTaKXeOTHeEeHMeM .
Mble BeUM.
flpaB!4lOM, M3nOXeHHblM Bn.
KHefi HaM60nee UeHHMX 1/1 O˜U(˜CTBCHHO
Bbl˜˜a3a˜HOe CmeHMe npOlulBOfl0-
HM
aM 3Ha- IlOATBep˜eTcR
'iMMblX O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O B no MHeHMlo aBTOpOB,
30, 6 cr. 1 Y˜asa l p e 3 m e ˜ ˜ aPecnyGn˜˜w
.
nOXH0 M C MO 0 T M ' T flepeclB-lb HaBM-
HH I O , 4O f Ka3ax-
r MM-T
K craH0 ˜ 2 3 n e ˜ a 6 p ˜ 1 9 9 5 2723 ((06
r.Nz
npMMep˜blh ˜ F K T ˜ ˜ ˜TpeGyacnec(˜anb˜oc;I
X .
MMWM B pernaMewaUMMpamn MnoTeKe
H m m M M o r o ˜ ˜ y q e c r a a Cornacno eMy K
HenBMXHMOCTM B rpaX.f(aHCKOM ˜ O ˜ O T ˜ ,
o rT0
˜ H H n ˜MR R RBJlAeTCR BeCbMa PaalpOCTpa-
0U
3M n˜.
w n ˜ o f iKasaxcrane. Ha TO y˜a3blealo˜,
B TOM
B HaXOnMT OTpaWHMe B G‚¬&HHo˜T˜˜X
COAep- HWMMMOCMOMeCeHbl:3eMWbHble)NaCn<M,
'4MUle, MaTepHanbl HeAaBHO O ˜ $ ˜ M K M ˜ H H O ˜ XaHMn MHOrMX ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ B o o T H o L0 ˜ H M ˜ ˜ aTaKXe 3aaHMSI. C0OP)'XeHMRH H O MMYqeCr-
u 0 6 0 ˜, He
@oPM˜ 80, npCHHO C R a H e c 3e˜neA.
T.e. 06lbe˜˜bl.
flOpRnKe M MKlllO'4eHMR AOrOBOPOB, B 3H O
K0H@peH˜MM3.
Y˜sepxnenue0 6 neperne
OTKP˜ITOM IlpenMeTOM KOTOPblX R n e C HenBMXMMOe
BRT R nepeMeqenMe KOTOP˜IX 6e3 ˜ e ˜ o p a 3 ˜ e p ˜ o r
y q e c r ycraHoenenMn oco6blx npaeMn
HeaBMXMMOCM C B O ˜ T B ˜ H H O ˜ O C C M ˜ C K O ˜ ˜ ˜
˜ ˜o, yyep6a MX Ha3IiaWHMOHeB03MOXHO. n a H ˜ 0 e
!4
n.B. M R npcl06peTPHM1l npaea C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H ˜ ˜ nonoxeHue co3sy-1˜0 1cr. 117 TK B peClaKuw
n.
Ha ˜M
˜ M B M ˜ M c T aOk3pMHbl. HanpMMep,
M'˜˜˜Ko˜˜
H W B M ˜ M M O CM e' p ˜ e a p y ˜ x c n y a efel .p ˜ 3 a ˜ o OTa MapTa 1998 r.
U˜HHMKOB˜ ˜2
˜˜
BbuenneT cnayloqbte xapaKTep-
w e qeprbl H ˜ ˜ S M X M M ˜ M : 3 O QCO˜O
TM ilOA'-IepKMBaeTCSI, YO npaB0˜0fi
T 603BpaU@flcb ClpylcrypeHeABMMMOCM,
K
OTBeMTb H BOflpOC: LT , co6Cr-
1) yreT 3 a ˜ o ˜ o a a ˜ e n e ˜oTwceHMM
npM , PeXMM OTaenbHblX EMROB He&BMXMMOrO H!˜O˜XOAMMO a cO
apyr no
erne-
Bell.leh K HeaBMXMMOMY MMYUeCTBY, MMyqenea c y q e m e n H o oTnMraeTcR CocTasnReTnoHmeH W M X M M O ˜
B˜HHO,
OT npyra6. PecnyGn˜˜cll
cTeeHHblX CBO˜CTBnoUleaHcrlfi, B YXTHOCTM, r p a m ˜ l a ˜ c˜ ˜ ˜ y o m ˜ e
˜o o ˜ nbrny
Ha HaLU B3rnRn. MHeHMeOnpMMepHOM(He-
MX HaXOXQJeHMfl B OaHOM M
H!˜O˜XQAMMOCT˜ Ka3axcra˜?
Bnon˜e
T M M MeCre; ˜ ˜ K P ˜ I T O M ) WHe06be˜˜0˜
nep HWBMXMMOCM VTO OCHOBY ˜OHRTMR
O oresvlnno,
2) npmeHeHue 3 a ˜ o ˜ o a a ˜ e n e ˜ OCHOBblBaeTCfl He Ha nOnOXeHMM YKa3aHHOM
AnR H˜BMXMMO˜M
cocraensleT3erm, npaewlbnee
- 3eMWlbHblR y.laUOK. 3eMnn Tpap,MuMOHHO
BblLUe fl. 1CT. 17, a H CO,Ll$pXaHMM 23˜0G e
x
Kpyra a fl.
o 6 0 3 ˜ a r e n ˜ ˜ ˜ e n ˜ u x l t l ˜ o c rMeTom
et2
c m b TK, cornacHo˜ o ˜ o p m y B M X M M ˜ I M B B e cTpaHaX RBnReTcsl 0 ˜ 0 6 b06beKTOM
˜ KH ˜
IlePHR, K O T O P ˜ ˜ ˜
He RBJlileTCR MCrlepilblBalO- O CX l˜
nowexaqme IlpaBa CO˜CTI˜˜HHOCTMM bX BeWbIX flpaB. B
B e w M npMpaBHMBatom Tawe M Hl
WM;
pemopauww ˜ o s a y u ˜ b ˜ Kasaxcra˜esa˜o˜onal-enb˜a˜
3) 3aKOHO˜Tenb tiam menerenun
YCTaHaWlMBW OC06blh rocyaapcree˜˜oci e
M MOPCKHe CyAa, Cyaa BH'flQeHHerO 3eMnM BT ˜ ˜ W ˜ H C O˜OPOTTOJI˜KOCO˜AXT-
KM˜˜
npameoh p e x l n ˜
HepSuxmoro uhnyuema, BOnHOrO
qm nnaeaHMfl s p e ˜ a - ˜ o p KOC-,
˜ 0 ˜ 0 p b OCHOBblBaeTCR Ha H˜O˜XO˜MMOCTM
lfi nnaeaHnil, e˜ CR. 3a CpaBHMTeflbHO K O ˜ ˜ T K VflepHOn 6b1no
I˜?
o 6 e c n w ˜ y n r o A ˜ ˜ ˜ m 3 MMY-
˜c npaB na 0 M 'e K e 0 6 b e ˜ ˜ b l .
MC M
i npM3TOM 3aKOHOaaTWIb- R M R O T M HOPMaTMBHblX flPaBOBMX aKTa,
P HT P
uemo M onposenw˜n HMMM alcraMM K H ˜ B M X M M ˜ IBeqaM MoxeT
M
CneqwibHoro nopqq˜a pe˜ynMpylo˜X
3eMWIbHbleOTHOLlteHMRHapRAy
Pecny6nu˜˜
c TK: 1) Y K f l˜p e 3 ˜ ˜ e m a
pacnopmietinn MM˜. 6 b b O H C H M M O MMY˜KIEO.
TeeO He Ka3ax-
I l p o a ˜ a n m ˜ pconepxaHMecoorseTcr-
ye˜
B ˜ a 3 a x c r a ˜ c ˜ o R ˜ ˜ M C T M ˜ ˜ HayKeA
˜MB CKO aaH, ˜ ˜ e f o u t CMny 3aKOHa. O 22 ae˜a6pfl
lR T
1995 r.N?27170 3 e ˜ n e2) ; a ˜ P e t n y h ˜ ˜ ˜
˜3 o˜
Ha yKa3aHHble OCO˜˜HHOCTH
HeaBMXMMOcM BylOuvlX ˜ ˜ ˜ A ˜ M 3aKOHa. M R
C˜H
2001 r. N 152-11 "0
no naueMy MHenMm, O
Hanp˜˜ep, rnasHan TPYP)IOCT˜ Ka3axcra˜ 24 FIHB˜PR
06pawe˜CRMenblue BHMMaHMe. OT

'fiZUW?BT K T 3M T p H b 6 ˜ ˜fl0Tp6nll˜bCII
e Ce eM Hl 4˜ BKa'lKlBe C H H M B
UOW O
K CWlbIIM 117,118,155 / r p a m p ˜ l K n K ˜ h O M H M3 S H eBun.
˜ C : SOPUCOBB M., hlbRc0Ba K M. KouMe˜˜apR
M ˜ ˜ ˜ Pecny6n˜˜u
Oe C Ka3axcra˜OK BH e
- JO a M
Tl MK M e T !O a M.
4. An˜aTbl. 1997 C 1
.8
CM.:& K ˜ K ˜ ˜ n oB m H˜˜,E˜WXWMOCMmroHomTenbcreyPecnyGnuw KaMxcran; K ˜ C ˜ O H.B.Conepxanue n o m f l t c ˜ ˜ e ˜ x ˜ ˜ ˜ yaqe c f s / *
H.P. O ˜ e B.˜
no e o
hn
06b˜KTbl rpamHacWx ilpaB: MaTep˜anbl ˜ewcpy˜aponnoi ˜ ˜ H O - ˜ ˜ K T U ' KOH@P˜HUMM (BpaMW Wer0p)cblXU B n c .e K X H H ˜ ˜ ) .
M M W Ml C U W /i.JIhda˜bl,
25-26
H˜ ˜˜CKOR
2003 r. / OTB. p a . M.K. CyndMeHoB. AJlMa˜bl: Ka3WY. 2004. C 105-111;C. 119-124cooT6eTmeHHo.
.
CW˜R˜PR
n B. 8eqnble npam B r p a l y q a ˜ c ˜ o ˜ POCCWW.C. 12-13.
˜L(‚¬!HHMKOB˜ npase
* npam I.( c o 6 m e ˜ ˜ Monorpa$˜n. ˜ M ˜ T M :
m: Xenxaprw, 1998. C. 118.
A
Dr., Macwltlr M I . HenBnxnMoeu ˜ y q m onpaeosoe perynuposanue. Hayr˜o-npamreacoeo c h e . M.: blw-eo 6EK, 1997 C 2.
Xapu˜os : n .
rK
K h o ˜ n o n o x e ˜ ˜ oMM BCPHMCII npn BbrRsneHuno ˜ n n r unpameoro pexum ABMXMM˜IXM H ˜ ˜ B W M M Xeeqei.
y i
Bepxos˜oroCoeeTa 1995 r.. N 24, cr.165.
n
*Be&o˜om PK.
B e n o m BepxosnomCosma PK, 1995 r., N?24, cr.159; Kaaxcra˜c˜an npawa 0 ˜ 2 ˜eKa6p˜ r.
6 1995
teopwn npasa


r0 3 a i H R neCHOrO M BOaHOrO @yq˜B.˜ T M XMMOCM. B3aKOHO˜TenbCTee
H Ce M , YAUeHbl T n K
Ob O
o 6 q ˜ nonoxeHvr57.T ˜ Kcornaao n. 1 cr. 117TK
e
3eMenbHble Y a m M , fl˜KM'it?CKM ,
HeMBMOIMO
PK KTaKOBblMOTHKeHbl:3aaHMR,COOpyXeHMfl,
KaTe-
O MX flPMHaPJleXHOCM O ˜ P ˜ P , W I ˜ H H &
T K
T P M IlOTeHIJrlanbHOMOryr 6 b n o 6 b e ˜ l a ˜ M MHoronemMeHacameHm M w o e ˜uyqecreo,
OM ,
anpegeneHMe 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ oyracrKa BHeceHo
ro
npOCiH0 C R a H e C3eMnefi. T e T 06bem1,
T ˜ K B COOTBWOBMM C n. 13 ff. 12 3K
,
He 6bmo. COBepweHMR rpaX.4aHCKO-flpaBOBblX˜ W ˜ O K ' ˜ . B 3H O O Cb
- BblAeneHHaR B 3aMKHy-
3eMenbHblfi y.laCTOK OIlweneHHblfi BO˜pCKBO3HMKaWOBb˜eneHMM nepeMeqeHMe KOTOP˜IX 6e3 ˜ e c o p a 3 ˜ e p ˜ o r o
n. 1 U.
OXpaHReMblX npM- yqep6a MX Ha3HaCieHMlo HeB03MOXHO.
T ˜ I X rpatiMUax Ciacrb ˜˜MJ-IM, a ˜ p e n n ˜ B ˜ a XMUbHblX yaCKOB 0 ˜ 0 6 0
3 e ˜
nopnalte 3a c y 6 b e m a ˜ ˜ Po.QHblX˜eppMT˜pMfi, 130 r p a w ˜ c ˜ oKoneKca P o c c ˜ k ˜ o fw e -
Oi
ycraHoeneHHohn 3K 3eMenb 03.4OpBblTeJlbHO- ro
3eMUbHblX O T H O U ˜ H M ˜ ˜ . Ka'4eCTBe 06qer0 paIJrlMnpe.qnaraeT 6onee paseep˜yrblfi
B r0, pKpaUj40HHOrO M MCrOpMKO-KynbTypHOrO nepe-
r n 3 e ˜ n cycTaHoeneH npaeoeok
˜ Ha3Ha.leHMfl. ˜ O X M B L L I ˜ R C cya6HaR npaKTMKa
npasuna l WHb HeQBMXMMOCTM, O H c Clona, nOMMM0
T OR
R
3HaeT TaKMe flpMMepbl. T ˜ K OflpefleneHMeM
,
PeXMM ˜ o c ˜ . Q ˜ ˜ c TCO˜CTB˜HHOCTM.
B˜HHo˜˜ 3eMUIbHblX Y'iaCKOB, YCiaCKM Hap, 060˜06-
Konnemm no rpaxqaticKm nenaM neHHble BoaHble 06bem1, neca, MHoronemMe
Clacr˜onpaeosofi( r p a m a ˜ c ˜ o - n p a e o e o k ) ˜ y a e 6 ˜ 0 h
06namoro cyna no MCKy npo-
p e x m 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ byacrKoe aonycKaeTcR Ha HaCameHMR, 3naHMfl, C O Y e M 1 T ˜ K M M
A˜˜M˜TLIHcKo˜O
lx O P XH F.
ociiosaHnRx, y c n o s ˜ M B npmenax, ycraHoe-
˜x KYpaTpbl6b1˜10 npM3HaHO 3aKOHHblM PellleHMe o6pa3o˜,M T T M npyr0G ˜0pMaTMBHblfi K
O aT
pako˜a nwOcTasneHw
neHHblX 3K (CT. 3 3K). o c 3˜ T
a M a Tanrapc˜oro
KM noHnme H ˜ B M X M M O C T M C B R ˜ ˜ I B ˜ e ˜ n e f i
3e˜nsl, c o o i - B ˜ T ˜ ˜ B M M˜ i a c r ˜ ycl o G C T B ˜ H H p - ˜ 3. xMenbHoro
O r˜
B Kaaaxcra˜e y
c
B B (3eMenbHblMM ˜ ' ˜ ˜ c T K ˜ M M )
MCO,4ePXMTflpaBbl-
y a r n a B yporMqe 6enb6yna˜. Ha oc˜oee no, UlWyfl K O T O ˜ ˜ M Y
4eneet.lM H ˜ J H ˜ ˜ ˜ H M ˜ M , H cnayto-
pa3.˜ene˜a a Cya MOXHOHenOCpeP,CTBeHHO
w KaTeropm (n. 1cr. 13K):
e aekmyioqero B TOT MoMetiT q. 1a. 18 Ym3a o H npamKeonpenenclTb, nwvwcma MnM w a n
a
3eMne flO‚¬TaHOBWl, '-TO3. RBflfleTCR C O ˜ ˜ H seqb H ˜ B M X M M O ˜ ˜ .
1) 3eMnM c ˜ ˜ ˜ c K o x o ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ Ha3Ha- H H O ˜ O
CIB˜ -
HMKOM xmoro AoMa M B TOM c w a e K np˜o6-
CieHMfl; I/1H˜epecHylo C O ˜ ˜ H H O C UMBHnMCTM-
O T˜
PTaTenlonefEX0MM ˜ ˜ ˜ B O C C & ˜ B H H HrmoG ˜ O ˜ O K T P M H ˜TO MY Bonpocy 3 a ˜ e ˜ w - 1
2) 3 e ˜ HaceneHHblx ny˜moe;
n˜ ˜a O˜M no I
E.A. Cyxa˜oe,KOTOP˜IA y ˜ a s b ˜ ˜rro ˜ ,
3) 3eMJlM flpOMbllUneHHOcM, TpaHCnOpTa, 3eMWlbHbA yclaCTOKu. a e B Knac-
C R M 060˜0Hbl M OO H ˜ e n b ˜ ˜ 0 ˜ 0 3 f l f i C T - He BAaeaRcb B a ˜ a n ˜ e n e c o o 6 p a 3 ˜ o m cMlrecKoM o6opo˜e n a e ˜ o k e q b o BcerAa
r
B3 , M Hr ˜3 e
a
BeHHOrO Ha3HaUeHMR; M O˜˜CHOB˜HHOCM aaHH0l-0 pelueHMI1, TOnbKO flpM3HaeTCfi 3eMnR (3eMenbHblG YC˜˜CTOK),
ytaxew Ha TO, vro B HaueM 3a˜o˜oaa˜enbcree,n p M H w e x t i m l o - paenonoxeHHble Ha ˜ e f i
4) 3eMnM ˜ 0 6 OXpaHReMblX flPMV&HblX
0
M ripamice npeo6nwae˜ 06bem1,BKnman H ˜ B M X M M O C T ˜ . Y ˜ ˜ O B M R X
B
TeppM˜opvlk; npaeoeofi ˜ O K T P M H ˜
5) 3 e ˜ necHoro Qowa; PaCCMOTpHMM3eMenbHblXyarnOB BK 'e T e aCB
i
n˜ nPM3HaHMfl ˜ ˜ K J l l o ˜ M T e fCO˜CTBCHHOCTM
lb˜˜k
6) 3 n p ˜ ˜ a r n e x ˜ o c 3 e f i ˜ M c o o p y x e ˜ ˜ k , rocyAapcrea H
e BOAHOrO˜
˜ @OHna; r na ˜k a B oTerecTeeHHoM npa-
npM
a He H ˜ O ˜ O ˜ O T . 3TOM BaXHO OTMCTMTb,
7) 3 e ˜ 3anaca. BOflOpaKernaBHblM06WKT0MC W l M ClVrraTbCR

npM 3TOM O˜WKTOM rpaWHCKOr0 060- vro ceronHR cyqecreyeT onpe,qeneHHaR 3 a ˜ o - paCnOJlOXeHHbleHa 3eMJle3AaHMR, COOp˜eHMil
poTa craHoeMTcR3e˜nn˜ stex ˜ a r e r o p ˜ ai , HonaTenbHan 6a3a p i n o6opo˜a e ˜ e n b ˜ b i x M TOMy noao6˜ble 6 b e ˜ ˜ b38, KOTOpblMM B
f
He 3 0 1
2-4 CT. 23, Cne-
ponb 3necb MrpaloT HOPM˜I
T n K HeKOTOPblX M H X (CM.n.n.
Ob O 3M p a r n o s . rnae˜ylo Ce
y
J
W
l MX OT'4YweHMR a T M T 'e K
B O a Mi C M
06 HnOTeKe M 3K. ao˜ano
npaeo 3 e ˜ n e n o n b 3 o e a ˜ l˜ ˜ ˜
f p .TOM
cr. 24 w apyrme 3K). M YKa3a KaK 3 O H flapWOK-
T e
Ha Bonpoc, IcaKMe
CanbHO3aMeTMTb, rK B06OpoTe HQJBMXMMOCM
C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ byqacntm Haxoamcn
le
O aBTOp YKiuMBaeT, TO flPM3HaHMe 'iaCIH0fi c06-
B rpamaHCKOM a6opo˜e MOi-yT n M 6blTb WHO
MrpaeT ˜ e 3 ˜ a r ˜ ˜ e nponb, tMo6onbuan
b˜y CTB˜HHOCM H 3 e ˜ n t o
a aBmMamCieCKM
M
no r a m ero HOPM o AO˜OBOPH˜IX
npmMeTaMu cpenoK, B 3a˜o˜oaa˜enbcree 06fl3aT˜˜ibCTBa˜ BneCib BO3BpaT K TPa,L(M˜MOHHOMY flOpsCOP.y,
no n e w a r e MMyqecrea˜ o n m o e a ˜ ˜ e e omympaTenb w n p ˜ o 6 p e ˜ a ˜ e n b
n n p KOTO˜OM
˜
CMX nop H aaH CieTKMk OTBeT. B ˜ e c r o MnM
e TOrO,
6yw, npewe Bcero,
˜06b13aKo˜oJ1,aTenbHooflwenKb KaTerOpMM C O ˜ C I B ˜ H H O C ˜ X W IlpMMeHeHaTOnbKO o 6 b m WWMMOCM
MO ˜˜˜
FluaTb onp poco c y p b 6 e 3 e ˜ n H , K O T O ˜ G
3eMenbHblX Y i C K B KOTOPble MOi-yT 6 b l ˜ b no aHanoMM, ˜ c n o n b 3 y ˜ u e nonoxeHMR,
o6
Ca T O , ˜a OH
pa˜fl0n0xeH". K ˜ m e 6bmo H M OTMWeHO,
K
06be˜˜aML-l flpaBa CO˜CTB˜HHOCTM M MHblX HanpMMep, ˜ y n n w - n p o a a x ˜
M MMyqemeHHo- aM
r 0 HafiMa, MX OTnenbHblX P ˜ ˜ H O B M A H O C T ˜ ˜ M .˜ Tawe npwepxMeaehncR 3˜017 O ˜ M ˜ M M
˜I
BeqHbDc npaB, ˜ K T O ˜yl<a3blBaeT,p l KaKMX
˜KO CR ˜ M
c l m e u , vro ˜ n b ˜ e f i u p ie e m e rpaxg,aH-
uenek cooTseTmyloqMe s e ˜ e n b ˜ pacrKvl 06pa30˜,3 e ˜ e n b ˜ by e m v l RB-
la
˜KMM
b˜e eu
nRloTCFl OCHOBHblM 06bemo˜ HenBMXMMOCM.
MOXHO
npeaocraenmoTcg. Cnenoea˜enb˜o, C OO o6opo˜a
Kr 3eMenbHblX paCTKOB M MHblX
HOflOHRTMe HQBMXMMOCrM OTHlOab He Molep-
3aKnlo.IMTb, W HerOCYaaPtTseHHblM cy6be˜-
O O6beKToBHWBMXMMOCMH C O T Jb On0Tpe-
a T R el H
6 y e nepecMorpa nonoxewfi 0 onweneHMM
˜ 6
T M Moryr 6blTb npepocraeneHb1 s e ˜ e n b ˜ b ˜ nblBaeTcfl 3 e ˜ n e k ,
a e KoropaR RsnfleTcn oreHb
yacmoe B K Ce T e n p ˜ ˜ a ˜ ˜ l e x ˜ o -
p a C T K M n ˜ 6 0 KaTeropMM. B˜XHO,q˜06bl B˜XHOG ee c a c ˜ a e n ˜ o q e HO ,He nepecTaeT 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ b 1 x
MX
k ˜7 a iC B
K ˜ G H M ˜ M COOPYX˜HM˜.
6 b n nMWb 0,QHMM 3 O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T B 3 O nnaHe
O B .M
MCnOnb30BaHMe C O B T T O a l YKa3aHHblM
O T e C B B JO M T W
nOCTaTOCiH0 Cepbe3Hyio npo6ne˜y
B 3 a ˜ o qennM (cr.cr. 23 M 24 3K).
˜e npep,craB- f l a ˜ ˜ b lT i3 C flOfiTBepwaeTCR npaK-
fC M
nReT co6oG M O HeaBMXMMOe MMylL(eCTB0, npasoBoro perynmpoeatim P ˜ ˜ B H T ˜ I X
He Bbl3blBaeT C O M H ˜ H M O CO Ha npaBe He TMKO˜
T, T
˜i
CTpaH. H a n p ˜ ˜ e H , ˜ P L yKa3blBaeT.
pH O U
C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H O C TM npase 3 e ˜ n e n o n t ˜ o s a K ˜O O Mbl CKflOHHbl OnPnWflTb B KaCiecTBe
˜ T˜ e
Op M
M
flpeAOCraBfleHbl3eMeJlbHbley-lacn<M,
˜oryr6brrt, n p ˜ ˜ a m e x ˜ a c T e R e n b ˜ o y o a m a (cr.
ae˜ rq C O <<...Ha3aCTPOeHHblX 3eMenbHblX YUacTKaX
T
i
a He H ˜ O ˜ O ˜ O T .
omeceHHble, HanpMMep, K 3 e ˜ n cenbc˜oxo-
n˜ 122 rK), flpMHUMflManbH0B e 3AaHMfl M VaCM 3 . ˜ a ˜ w i 1
C C
B ˜ ˜ H O G 3peHMR MMeloTTY Xe npaBOBylo
O n m e n e ˜ ˜ lp ˜ ˜ m e x ˜ o c r e k
no 3e˜enb- TWKM
˜ R ˜ C ˜ B ˜Ha3HaCieHM8, HeKOMpblX 3eMenb
HHO˜O
HaCt?fleHHblXnyHKTOB, H K ˜ ˜ ˜ c K O X O ˜ R ˜ ˜ C ˜ B r H H O - O H C U X 3 ˜ 0 6 b e K T HWM-
H ˜ y'-lacn<a, T O R M C
OO a˜ n p ˜ ˜ w e x (rechtl˜ches
˜mb Schicksal), TO M

npasua, 0 ˜ 3RHsap 2001r. N 27-28. nanee B TeKcre - 3a˜on 3e˜ne.
n
Ka3axcrawa˜ 1 o
-
or26 UIOHR 2003 r. N 183-184,28 MIOHR 2003 r. N?186-187.name B TeKcre 3K.
n
Ka3axcra˜c˜an npa-
f l e w e ˜ 3eMenbHblX YaCKOB. K T p l MOrV H X A T U B rpmHCKOM Ohp0Te. C m H M X O npHBecMT n U npUMep˜blA, BMHYIO p n B 3 O Ur-
b O O be aOUb I e R R OH Ob O Ob TM
T.K.
3‚¬!Menb˜blfiK A CP K O T O P ˜ I ˜H˜CTORUHA M M H T n K npeAffOUTCO3pjlTb.C : flpaBUJla Be Ul rOCyRapUBeHHOr03eWbHOrO KWacTpa B PeCn@nll˜e
aar, B˜ O e T Ob O M -H f
Ka3axcra˜ ˜ 2 c ˜ H T R ˜2003 roua N! 958 / CAnn PecnyGnw˜u
! Kaaaxcran, 2003 r , N 38,
n
Ka3axffa˜. yrwpxuwb˜ flocrano˜nwue˜ flpaemenbcrea Pecnfin˜˜w 0 0 ˜R
cr 389.
' Ka3axcra˜. T ˜ T ˜O ,M H a U . npaKTuKa / fl0n pen. A r.˜ M & ˜ H8bln. 12. AnMSbl, 2001. c 182-184.
rpaWHCK0eM O O a e b l O Pecnfin˜˜M
K H R T n CB C KU e T P M
M Ko.
" r p a ˜ & 3 H ˜npaso: 6 2 ˜T.M 1 Y V ˜ ˜ H / OTB. pa. nfX@.E.A C ˜ X ˜ H O B . U R, nepepa6. M O . M.: H˜A-Bo 6EK, 1998. C.310.
MK
˜0e O. 2-e 3 . An
reopnn npaea


... 3003Ha'4aeT, W C
C M 3 e ˜ ˜ b H bPaCTOK
a lh O
aacrpoh˜oh coopy)l(eH@ CTaHoBmcfl cornam0
g 93 rK ( r e p ˜ - C.C.) c˜ q e c r s e ˜ ˜ o h
a˜˜ y
COCT˜BHO˜
'4aCTbO 3eMenbHOrO YqaCTKa M
aBTOMaTM.leCKM nepeXOnm q C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H O ˜ ˜ ˜
5 946 rK),l5.
snaAenbua 3 e ˜ (CM.

Haao CKa3aTb, '4TO PaCCMOTpeHMe 3e-
B Kaqecree rnas˜o!?
MenbHoro y ama seqvl
xapaKTepHoe o n p e ˜ e n e ˜ n o i
cTenenMM m ˜ 3 a -
A˜H-
KOHOAaTeflbCla PecnyGn˜˜w
Ka3axc˜a˜.
HW06Cr0fl˜eflb˜˜0
HarnR.QHO)J,eMOHCTPMPyeT
npvlMep n p ˜ o 6 p e r e npae H caMoeonbnbre
˜˜e a
rK).
˜ ˜ c r p o s ˜ H ( 244
CT.
H ˜ npe˜craenfle˜a3acnym˜˜aloul&
M BHM-
MaHMeCTpylcrypaH‚¬!P,BWMMOCM,
KoTOpafl6bffla
npemoxena C.A. b e n f l u ˜ n B . TOM cnyvae
˜
HePBMXMMOClb-3TO 3eMR C B C ˜ M T ˜ MT 06-
O Y ,0
pa3yeTC˜ & l
COCfaBHyIO'4aCb.no˜M˜03ehnenb-
HblX )'VaCTKOBC.A. ˜ ˜ F I C ( K Hf?JJ3MXHMOCM
KM˜
omocm: TO, YTO n p H o H Hascerm( 6 e c c p ˜ o
- C.C.) CoeAHHeHO C 3e-h: COOpYXel-IMfl.KaK




noMoMei-rraoTpeneHMflWMH˜IOs e w c 3 e w h . cmse˜˜ocruu H ˜ W
nU seupbzx npas.
no MHWMIO6ennqor0, 0 C C a l-E@LDKHMOCM
O TB
- 003-
npocrpaHmo HW y a m o M
OTHOCMT˜
- M non pacn<OM, 8 r n y 6 ˜ ˜ e ˜ a c l e c r ˜ e T ˜ C T B ˜ H Hn pX˜ ˜ a m e x - CJ˜OXH˜˜P.‚¬!J˜O BO H U H Mnpo-
A Y L U H ˜ Io n 6
n˜ 6 ˜C ˜I O˜CTOMT T O e M
C˜MXn p ˜ ˜ a m e x ˜ o c3 e h e n b ˜ o y a n K a ,
re˜
HocreA 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ o yqacTKa nonxHo 6 b 1 ˜ b
ro
3 e ˜ HacronbKo, HacKonbKo n p o c ˜ ˜ p a e ˜ c n
n˜ ro
cr. 117 r ˜ .
n˜w". y ˜ a 3 a ˜ ˜B n.x npemne ˜ c e r o ˜ 0
o n p e ˜ e n e ˜ oTO, bl I
TO H B X O ˜ M T C R no^ no-
H
HWepec ynpasoMweHHoro 3
A˜HHW paCCMOTpeHMlo B KaqecrBe o6a-
BePXHOCTbIO 3eMenbhbl˜
YqaCTKOB: Henpa, OH C T R K
AOKTpMHaJlbHW nOnOXeHMe KOP- T O HC
peCnOHnMpyeT C O/JHMM M I ˜ o ˜ ˜nehCT- H M ˜ HCKOnaeMbleM MMHepaJlbHWCblpbe
3 o x ˜ nOne3Hble e T B H A M M O T 3˜aHMh COOPYX˜HM˜˜,
KO eB X M CM M
3aKOHOfiaTHlbClBa. TaK, COrflaCHO 0 M 4pyrW. ) l n 3 M ilaCTeA HeClBMXMMOcM33- KOTOpble ˜ 0 ˜ 6 b m1) H n B P H C M M nop,
. $9 ˜ T X
EyIO˜erO b :a O e X O T
42 3K BeqHble nFBa Ha 3e˜eJlbHblh nOBepXHOClblo 3eMeJlbHblX YacTKOB, 2) npen-
)"WXOK KOHOAaTenb Y T H B n HKKOnbKO peXMMOB.
Ca OM
npasa rocynapneen˜oA
pacnpocrpaHfloTmHaHaxomwecRerpaHnyx 00-nepsb˜x,PXMM ˜ a 3 ˜ a r eMA b 1
˜ npoxMeaHMn M MMeTb w o e
B3
H CO ˜ C T B˜ H H O C T M l ˜l M
O C ˜ ˜ I ˜ $ OB ˜ H H ˜ B˜T M ˜ npWHa3HaCleHMe.
Ha Henpa, O˜
˜ T O ˜ O ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ O E ˜ ˜ X ,
6
3aMKHpleBOAOeMbl,fleCHbleHaweHMFI. ˜ P M qC
Mfe
l H nOne3Hble MCKOnaeMble (n. 3 C .
a T f l p a ˜ 0 ˜ 0 h X M M O O ˜ ˜ X ˜ pacn0-,
P˜ c HH˜
Pecny6n˜˜t.1˜ ˜ ˜ x c a Tame
KOHCMT˜UMM K T˜H,
TOM CO˜CTI˜CHHMK e ˜ e n b ˜ o yacrKa MnM
3 ro noxentiblx nop, noeepxHocTblo 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ o r o
enpase ˜ c n o n b a o ˜ a n n. ? CT. 5 Y ˜ a s a
no y a m a , perynnpyeTa y ˜ a s o Hapax. .T˜K,
˜
3wnenonb3oea˜enb npe3wema, ˜ ˜ e l o u l ec m y
ro
%KOH˜, "0 Hapax M H ˜ ˜ o ˜ ˜ o ˜ ˜ ˜ o B ˜ H COrflaCHO.n.n. 1 M 25 0 . 1 yKa3a OnepaQHRMH
C B ˜ ˜ Y C M O T # ˜ H M K ) M & ˜ ˜ X O A ˜ ˜ no- C M 7
MH"")
H˜O MO
˜ b H y n )pa6on1
ece, Bo-BTOP˜IX,none3˜ble no H ˜ A ˜ O ˜ O ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ c ˜H K a l o ˜ :
UcKonaeMble, 6 y n y w
ny-reHMnK ˜ K M X - p a 3˜ e u e ˜ ˜ A \cro Ha-
˜ M p˜
X A T R HWM nO˜nOWpXHOCTblo3TOTO)'VaclKa, OTAeneHHblMMOT3eMenbHOrOYaclKa WH y a - no CTpOklT‚¬'JlbCTBy M 3KCMyaTauMM nOpeMHblX
O MC
CMa HWp, a) BblCrynatOTABMXMMblMMBeWMH, C O O P Y X ˜ H H ˜H CBR3aHHblX C noGblqeh, PJIfl
,e
e n TaKW MCnOflb30WHMeH HapyLUaeTnPBa
CM e
6) Ha HMX pacnpoc˜pa˜ne˜cn T c m y l o u ˜ h o6qero X O ˜ ˜ I ˜ C T B ˜ H H O ˜sO˜ a v ea Tatwe
p,pymxnMumH rocympma,BTOM wtcnenpasa ˜a ˜˜n,
cme
H H w a , BOnbl, neCa M B03AYUHOe npOCrpaH-
a npaBOB0h PeXMM H B) M O V npHHarneXaTb J(JlR 3aXOpOHeHMR panMOaKTMBHblX OTXOnOB,
Ha npaee
˜ e ˜ p o n o n b s o e a ˜ e n ˜ ˜ C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H O - BpeFIHblx seqecre M CTWHMX eon. H e n o c w -
CIBO. T˜KMM 06pa30˜,MOXHO 3a˜nt0qm, YTO
m ( 5 ˜ O Bo H p a K) .
K O H ˜ ˜ ˜ L ( M R ˜ ˜ U H ˜ P ˜ ˜ ˜ M O C M ˜ ˜ ˜a˜. M Y˜a3a˜ ˜ e˜˜B ˜ xB-WT˜MX, npaso crseHHo perynMposanwo npasosoro pexMMa
OTHOCMTenbHOeCTeCWHHblXnpHHaPllWOCreh nOCTORHHOr0 M &3003˜e3flH0r0 He,L(pOnOnb- ˜OOpyXetiklh
no# IlOBepXHOCTbIO 3eMenbHOrO
o
19 Y ˜ a 3 a
30BaHMR nwocraBneHo ˜wpononb3oea˜en10
ae˜enb˜oroyama,
ywatitiblxeblure. 3 0 6 ˜ - yclacrKa nocsRueHa TonbKo CT.
n e ˜ 0 3 ˜ a q aYTO npMoriyweHHM s e ˜ e n b ˜ o r o Ha 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ b l x y a c r ˜npmtiamexaqmx eMy n. 1 ˜ o ˜ o p o h
ax,
˜b. nenpax, B K CrpoMTenbcTBy M
p a m a , ecnu 06 ˜ a n p a ˜ e ˜ a m ˜ c o MnwnocroaH-
he˜˜om
TOM B a T 06 OTqywetiMM
Ke 3˜cnnya˜au˜˜
nopSeMHblx c o o p y x e ˜ u i ,
He
mn
npw npMMeHwloTcfl npaeuna
CneUManbHo H n w y c M o q x ˜ o
e MHW, K Horo 3e˜nenonb3oea˜˜fl, ocyulecrenenwn c˜˜3a˜˜b1xcao6b1rlefi,
˜06b1˜˜06ulepacnpocrpa˜e˜˜b1x o Heapax, C B R ˜ ˜ H c noGbrqefi, ecnH
nepexoART Bce n p M t i w e x H o m none3˜b1x
06peTa˜enlo YKa3a H˜I˜
MCKOnaeMblX m f l C O ˜ ˜ B ˜ H H ˜ I X(n. 3 CT.
42 Hymn
3eMenbHOrO FacTKa, npOqyCMOTpeHHbleCT. MHW He npwyCMOTpeH0 3aKOHOnaTeflbCTBOM.
n. 2 3 ˜ 0 h CraTbM YKa3blBaeT Ha H ˜ O ˜ X O ˜ ˜ M -
10 Y˜a3a H ˜ A P ˜ X ) .
3K, ˜e T ˜
H C ˜ ˜ U M ˜ J ˜˜˜0 ˜ O B ˜ P M B ˜ HWO. 0
3 OH Xe

MH˜OI W .OT˜enb˜ble eonpocbl npaea Ha HWWMOU˜ B r e w a ˜ n w K ˜ M x ˜ 0 6˜m 1rpawlAaHcKMX npae: M a r e p m u ˜W.,n,y˜apo˜noR y q ˜ o - n p a m e -
n H / ˜a
˜
w.M.K. C y n G w ˜A˜hnaTbl.KiuWY, 2004 C. 100.
CO KCH˜˜˜HUMM
KO (BPaMKitX eXWOLIHblX UBWlMcnlreOcwX h ˜ a ˜ b l , cem6pn 2003 r. /Om.
25-26 .
6enflwnA C.A. qacrHw npaso B OCHOBH˜IX npnelumax: Kypc rpawaHcKoro npaea. K ˜ Y H ˜ C , C. 209-210.
1928.
OT 27 flHBdpR 1996 r. NI 2828 0 HeApaX M HeLIpOnOnb3OEaHMM / KasaxcraHciaflnpasm, OT 29
bIMt?lOul˜ii LKOH˜,
y˜a3 pe3˜WTa ˜ c ˜ @ ˜ H K H
n P Ka˜xcraH. cMny
atieapfl1996 rom. p,anee - Yias o Hapax.
reopus npasa


flpo6ne˜ w b ˜ e f i w TK He nopvnHneTeroaeToMaTMqe-
M K b nOn!P-leHMR nMueH3MM Ha CTPOMTenbCTBO CrMTaroTCR H&BHXMM˜IMM BeU@MM. e˜
n o p s e ˜ ˜ coopy- CKM BCeM 0 6 4 IlpaBMnaM 0 HWBklXMMOcM,
˜˜
u / ˜ Ha ˜
n sKcnnyaTauMro b˜x flpaKMCleCKM H e BO3HMKaeT C TeMM H a c a m e -
a ycTaHaencleaeTp,nfi W e n o K c npeAnpcllmmMM
XeHMfi, H e CBR3aHHblX C ˜ 0 6 b l q e nOne3HblX
i HMRMM, KOTOPble CO˜CTB˜HHYIK
nOCaAMn CaM M
6onee @0p˜aJlM30BaHHblfiM f f p O ˜
OCO˜˜IR,
KOTOPble, CneQOBaTenbHO, MMeKlT MCKYCCTBeH-
UCKOnaeMblX. i
xapawep. O
H˜IR
3paHMfl M COOPYXeHMR, KOTOPble PaCnO- n p e m e ˜ ˜ npo-rvleopewn
b˜e ˜˜xMM˜.
owe-
P.A. Ma˜e'roaa 6.B. ˜ O K P O B C K M ˜ ˜
B 3 a ˜ o ˜ o p a ˜ e n b c B O e H M K ˜ OB cnyclae,
DOXeHbl Ha nOBepXHOCrM 3eMWlbHOrO y'-laCrKa, rs ˜ T M
ecnu H a c a m e H M R melo-r e c r e c r e e ˜ ˜ b rxa-
M o r y r 6 b m pByX ˜ a ˜ e r o pn W i :a 3 H a W H H b l e
˜fH q a m TonbKo pea KaLcecrea npepnpwwn KaK
fi
ochre o6be˜˜a
MR p o x M e a H m nropei M t i e x w n b l e ˜ A ˜ H M R pauep. Hanpn˜ep neca. C o r n a c ˜ o 3 cr.
- npaea:
n.
n M
6 nec˜oro KoAeKca P e c n y 6 n ˜ ˜ n 3 a x c r a ˜ 1) 3T0 H e npOCTO OAHa MnM HeCKOnbKO
COOpyXeHMR. f l p M 3TOM, eCnM OTHOCMTenbHO Ka
(8 MDnR 2003 ropa Ne 477-11 ) neca OTHOCRTCR Pa3HOPOfiHblX seqefi, a epMHblfi MMyUeCT-
mMnblX ˜ o M ˜ u ˜ H M ˜
3aKOHOflaTWlbCTBO pOfTa-
K C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H O C T M e c n y 6 n ˜ a 3˜ x c r a ˜
P K˜ a n
TWHO Pa3BKTO. TO ˜ O ˜ ˜ ˜ L I M H CHOPMaMBHblX
TBO B B H H ˜ KOMnneKC, 06bl'i˜o B K J l l o C l a l ˜ t l ( ˜B
h

MOW 6 b m npeAocrasneHb1 TonbKo Ha npaee
aKTOB no HeXMnblM nOMelL(eHMRM: a) IlpeMMy- c e 6 ˜ BeqM,
KaK TaK M MMyUeCTBeHHbIe n p a B a
H H ˜ I 6) J˜˜CO˜O˜˜˜OB˜HMR˜˜. Mo˜R˜˜HHOCTM;
U@CrBeHHO MMeloT ˜ O ˜ ˜ K O XapaKTep; ˜
f l p ˜ ˜ e aHanorMqHyto cmyauwlo 2 ) 3TOT KOMMeKC nPeAHa3HaCleHPJlR npeA-
p˜o
n w a 3 ˜ a r e ˜WRM M y q e m a , o m e c e H n o r o M˜I
br
Kr o ˜ y p a p m e H H 0 h O ˜ C ˜ B ˜ H H O C M . MMeeM C BOABMM. ˜ O T ˜ H ˜ M ˜ ˜ ˜ H n O v l H ˜ ˜ a T W l b c ˜ fl˜eJlbHO‚¬Tkl˜˜.
3aKOHO-
C p fie0 f i
no HalueMy
Ocyqec˜ene˜˜e
npasa C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H O C T M QaTenbCTBO H e MCKnloClaeT MX M3 O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O B MHenMlo, n p e A n p M m e B Ka-
oco6oro MMyUKiBeHHOrO
r a C T H 0 i cO˜CTB˜HHOCWI, B TO Xe BPeMR YC-
Ha x M n b l e n o M e q e H M R pernahneHTMpoeaHbl HO CleCTBe KOMMeKCa
P˜ C ˜ ˜ ˜ J IKasaxcra˜ 16 a n p e n g
MKM TaHaenueaeTp.nR HMX pemMM rocypapcree˜˜oi Henb3R nPM3HaTb HH B KaClKlBe HepaMXMMOrO
˜˜KOHOM OT
1997 r O n a Ns 94-1 "0 XMnMUHblX OTHOUIeHM- w y q e c r s a , HM B KaqecrBe 0 6 b e ˜ T aBeqM,
CO˜CTB˜HHOCTLI˜.
B KaLcecrse oco6oro o6be˜˜a, T.e. o 6 b e ˜ ˜ anpasa CO˜CTB˜HHOCTH MHblX
RX"". U X ˜ P M H ˜ M ˜ M C O˜ ˜ H H O C T ˜ ˜
O˜ ˜˜ O˜O OTtieceHHoro M
RBflReTCfl TO, ClTO BCe OHM HenOCpeACTBeHHO K HeflBMXMMOMY MMYUleCTBY, BblCrynaeTflpeA- BeqHblX IlpaB.
A ˜ H HYTBepWeHMe CBR3aHO C TeM,

f l p M R T M e - ˜ a ˜ M ˜ y l ˜ ( e f l B e H HKOMnneKC (n. 1
blfi
npeAHa3Ha'leHbl MnM K O C B ˜ H H ˜0˜6M a s o ˜
p '-IT0
- npoxMeaHMe cr. 119 TK PK).
c rnas˜ofi ( e n b l o CrpyKlypy flpfWlpHRMR
˜
CBR˜˜H˜I KaK MMyQKiBeHHOrO
no
"0 K O H npW-
HOB M ˜ C T ˜ C T ˜ M ˜ ˜ XMnMu(HblX
rp-H. B n M T e p a ˜ y p e nOBO&'llPM3HaHMR KOMnneKCa 0 6 p a 3 y t o ˜H e TOnbKO BeUM, HO M
npyroe ˜ ˜ y q e m˜o ,˜ o p o p v l 3 s a ˜ o
o ne
npeClyCMaTpMBa‚¬!T BO3MOXHWb I l P M m F I B Ka'-l‚¬XTEe He&3klXMMOrO MMyqecTBa e b˜q-
OTHOW˜HMRX"
06be˜˜oe R
˜ c n o n b 3 o s a H M RyKa3aHHblX MW 6 b 1 nBblClca3aHbl pa3nMqHble CYXQeHMR.
˜ naTb O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O M
COOTBeTOBYOLqMXrpaX,4aHCKMX
-
no MHeHMlo 0.M. K03blpb, OC06blh XapaK-
M H ˜ I Xuenefi, H e C B R ˜ ˜ H H ˜ I npoxMsaHMeM.
cX npae, HanpnMep, M C K ˜ H ˜ ˜ M T ˜ n p aH o HaX
˜˜ s˜I
T ˜ Kcornaction. 2 cr. 1 9 3 a ˜ o ˜ can o n b 3 o e a ˜ ˜ e n p e p n p M f l T m KaK o 6 b e ˜ ˜p a m a H c K M x
ra
, HaMMeHOBaHMe, T O P T O B ˜ 3HaK M
I˜˜
˜ Tep @M˜M˜HHW
npas 3 a ˜ n l o l r a e ˜ crpex KaqeCTBax: 1) @ o p -
x M M O MnM ero C l a m no He- A p y M e . K ˜ O M ˜ T O ˜ O˜,e C T B e H H bKfO M W K C
C ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ H H M nK q a M B˜ M˜y li
mMnoMy ˜ a 3 n a . r e ˜ ˜ r o p e 6 y p a 3 p e u e ˜ ˜ ManbHO npepnpMRTMe He YnOMMHaeTCR B O n p -
tie ˜ e˜ n m n p M m R M o x w s K n t w a m wponm, o n m e -
˜
pWleHMM HwBMXMMOCrM B CraTbe 130 r K P@, a n e ˜ ˜ b l e o 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e na n pa B 0 ˜ 0 6 C T B e ˜ ˜ o c r v l
Ha 3T0 rOCY&aPCTBeHHblX OpraHOB, HO MOXeT bm ,
6 b m p e a n w 3 o e a ˜ CO˜CTB˜HHMKOM w b npM
o nM B c r a ˜ b e 1 3 2 KoTopaR p a c n o n o x e H a
, Ha 0 6 ˜ 3 a H H 0 f l k I RBnFleTCR HM'ieM MHblM, KaK
((BBONCRD
K)PM&M'iCCKMM HOHCeHCOM. Aanee, B CaMOM
6no˜a
co6nlo˜e˜˜˜ CTaTefi 0 HWBMXMMOCTM; 2) n0
CTPOMTenbHblX, CaHMTaPHblX, n0C.e
cocrasnnrounhn e r o m e ˜ e 0 6 b e a T 3 ˜ 0 ˜ H a - n o H m M ( ( n p e A n p M m e B 3 a ˜ n w e ˜ Kaqecma
˜˜ K˜
npOTMBOnOXapHblX M ApyrMX 06R3aTenbHblx br
CTOnbKO HeoAHOpAeH, ClTOOTHKeHMe er0 K T O ˜ o 6 b e ˜ ˜ a y 6 b e ˜ r pa w a H a < o r o npaea, M no
HOPM M npaenn. Mc ˜a
rpynne 0 6 b e ˜ ˜ o e
MOXeT 6bWb 0 9 - CYM, HanPMMeP B CJly'!a‚¬!COBepWHMFl˜M B
MnM M H O ˜
&‚¬T˜ToC˜HO
MHOrO BOllpCOB, B TOM ClMCne
M CBfl3aHHblX CO CTPYKTYPO˜ HepBMXMMOCTM, UeCTBneHO TOnbKO MCXOW M3 XapaKTepMCMKM OTHOlLIeHMMnpWIlpMKMR M K MMylL(KTBeHHOf0
˜ n ˜ q 3 ˜a o o ˜ o ˜ aero KaK oco6oro M M y q e c r e e n H o r o KoMnneKca,
nopopmno BeeAeHMe B x 0 HKKOnbWlX
˜e - KOMilneKCa, p W b p O n X H a
cJlWye˜ HO HeOCHOBblBaRCbHa npMpOAe C W a B n F l l o ˜ M X pa3nMClHblX loPM,4MqeCKMX C!4lyaWRX:
TeJlbCTBO nOHflMR ((KOWOMMHMYMa)).
er0 3neMeHTOB, M H O M e M3 KOTOPblX, TaKMe KaK eeqefi
He COrnaCMTbCR C PaCnpMTpaHeHHblM y HaC a) nepepaqa ( ˜ B M X M M ˜ I X He-
M
n p a B a T ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ H M R , MCKJlDClYITWlbHble
AOnrM, ˜BMXMM˜IX),
MHeHMeM 0 TOM, W O KOHpOMMHMYM eCTb CBOe-
6) nepeeopponra,
npep-
CYUpCTBylOUaFl @ p˜a npaBa, K HeABMXMMOCM H e OTHOCRTCR.
06pa3H.354, O ˜ ˜ C K T H B H O
B) ycrynKa ˜peGOsa˜m,
Ha ' ˜ . npMRTMe RBflReTCR HWBMXMMOCTblo H e B CMW
C O ˜ ˜ B ˜ H H O ˜ M HalU B3rJlm, IlpaBMnbHee
r) n e p e X 0 p
ero ˜ e p a s p b ˜ e ˜CoBf R ˜ ˜ H H O C T M3 e ˜ n e i ,a
c
erOOnWWlMTb KaK ˜ ˜ y q K T B e H H b KOMMeKC
lfi i MCKnloClMTenbHblX n p a B M
kl MMeHHO 3AeCb KOHL(en4MR no PeLueHMK, 3aKOH0,QaTeJlfl PaCnpOCTpaHMTb apyroe.
HeABMXMMOcM.
b ˜ f r o K - rnaeHaR s e q b , a ece T ˜ K M M 6 p a 3 0 ˜ ,nepep HaMM a e n K a ,
Ha 3TOT C n e ˜ ˜ @ M ' . l e C ˜ M f˜ ˜ C OCO&HHOCM
Oi KT
ae˜enb˜ Waci o
npaeoeoro pexnua, 06be˜nloua˜
cO60fi HeCKOnbKO lopWM'ieCKMX
WR
ycraHaenMsaeMoro
npOClMe HeABHXMMOCTM RBJlflKlTCR e r O n p M -
3)
HepBMXMMOrO MMyLU,eCTBa; npe,QnpMFlTHe n0HFlTMh M KOHCTPYK˜M˜˜. ˜ T O M Y ,
HaCKOnbKO
˜O
HweXHOCWMM)) B q n a e T B nPOTMBOPWMe C
cue RenReTcR O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O M ˜ o p b ( ( s b l n w a e m 143
˜o , lfi HaM M3BeCTH0, HM OAHa nOnblTKa n p M 3 B e c M
flefiellcrByloI.44˜3aKOHOAaTWlbCIBOM, q e M y
6 y ˜ yAeneH0 BHMMaHMe HMXe.
e˜ K J ˜ ˜ c c M @ M K ˜ HepBMXMMblX M ABMXMMblX
˜MM r o c y m p c r e e H H y o peMcrpaqMro n p e p n p M m R B
e e ˜ e f inOCK0nbKy OH0 BCqbK), m eC˜OXHOL?,
X
, nocr. 119 TK MAPYMM
K a q e m e HWBMXMMOCTM
P a 3 n ˜ ˜ l n bHe c w e H M f l H a noeepxHocrM
la
˜ M B M J ˜ M C T M C ˜ ˜ C K e n e n n e ˜ cAanee aerop y ˜ a m e a e C˜TO,
˜˜. ˜, ycnexou. P e r ˜ c r p ˜ p y l o q e ˜ y
SeMenbHOrO YClaCTKa B HO ˜ He yeeticlanacb
AOKTPWHC, A0 MOMeHTa OT#eneHMfl, T a K x e n p ˜ 3 ˜ npepnpMRTvle H e p m w w M o c r b r o , B
as o p r a H y y p a n o c b TonbKo 3 a p e r ˜ c ˜ p n p o ˜ a ˜ b


'Ka3axcra˜c˜a˜ OT 19 anpen8 1997 r.
npaena,
'CT. 2 3aK0˜a XWlMUHblX OTHOWeHMflX, a TaK Xe CM.: ˜ ˜ C O .H Hosoe B XUJlMulHOM MKOHOAaTeJlbCIBeKa3axCraHa / rpaXAaHc˜oe
0 Mr 3aKOHOAaTWlblTBOPecny6n˜-
I(M Ka3axcra˜ -TOnKOBaHMe H KOMMeHTMPOBaHMe.8blIlyCK 5.˜nMaTbl'TOO a6acnan. 1998 C. 54.
2003 r.. Ns 16, cr.140.
a B˜AOMOCTM n a ˜ e P e c n y 6 n Ka3axcra˜,
nap ˜˜a ˜˜˜
2003 roAa Nn 481-11 / K a a x c r a ˜ c npaspa, 17˜10nn2003 roAa Nz 206-207
˜'CM. 8 H ˜p BOAHO˜O KoneKca Pecny6n˜˜u Ka3axcra˜ 9 wton˜ ˜a˜
CT. OT
' /
K03brpb 0.M. H˜AEM˜MMocT˜ B HOBOM rpa)l(qaH˜˜OMKWeKCe POCCMM6 KH :˜ P ˜ W @ H C K H ˜ Pocmu flflne˜bl Teopufl. flpaKTkl˜a'
KOneKC C˜OPHMK MMRTCI C.A XOX-
nosa / OTB. p e ˜A.n. Ma˜osotmh; lRccnwosa˜enbutvlA e t q ramomnpasa M : MeXAy˜dpjqHbIh e t q ˜ ˜ ˜ a ˜ ˜ o s o - ˜ o ˜ o˜˜˜˜ ' B e 1998.C. 280-281.
. ˜ l MuM R r o
co,
u q
Ko3˜pb O.M. Y˜aaan˜oe cwMneHue. C 281-282
" rpXWHCKHh KOpeKC PWlyGnHKM KX3axffaH(06ulafl ˜ C l b ) K o ˜ w a p ˜Bh a KHHraX. KHHra 1. (3TB. pen : M K. CyJlehWH0˜. . r . 6amH. AnMaTbl, 1997. C. 297.
p. p 0
.
I
reopnn npasa


T ˜ K M 06pa30˜,MOXHO 3aK˜llo'-IMTb,
M
HblM YaCTKOM, 3aHMMaeMblM COOTBeTCTBylo- 'iT0
206CrBe˜˜0
HeflBMXMMOCTbBY K M 3 ai H M
3 O H 'e M
B X M ˜ M L L ( H OKOHL(efluMR c(3e˜enbHblfi ClaCTOK - rJlaBHaR
CnoBa (n. 1 cr. 1 7 TK). ˜ M ˜ , Q ˜ HM coopyxeHMeM.
M M˜M ˜ Y
3˜0ro 1
-
Beub, a ˜ A ˜ H MM CoopyxeHMR
caepe ero npw-
k l ˜ a MOXHO a e n a n
˜, R
06cro˜˜enbmo
ycyry6˜nocb eue
TO
npasapMTenbHble
M TeM, 'iT0 aHan0˜ClHblh
3e˜eJlbHblfi4aCTOK
y' H &e H C M)
a l X O T ), 00-nepBblX, AOnXHa 6 b l ˜ b
BblBOAbl:
6y˜yuue
nvluy, a sceM TeM, KTO
nemaeancn He OAHOM˜ paccimatia npeMMyqemeHHo Ha
1) n H T e M CTpyKTypy HeABMXMMOClM
O RM
O H W H R B c@epe HepBHXMMOCM, M, BO-
y.laCTOK M W IlpMHaA- np˜eam3˜poean
mwnbe. TO eM
o6pa3ye˜
3e˜WIbHbli O
BTOPUX, AonmHa sblcrynam B K a m e o6qer0
8 PaCCMarpMMeMbIXCqauMRX KOHUellLU.IR
nextloon: ˜ A ˜ H M coopyxeHMR, MHoroneniMe
R,
- rnasHan e e w , a 3 ˜ a -
HacaqeHMR M MHoe ˜ ˜ y q e mnpowio CBR- c e e ˜ e n b n bYacToK
˜i npaBMna, MCKJllo'ieHMeM M K T p r AOnXHa
3 O O OO
o,
HMR M CoopyxeHMR - ero npMHamemHocrM))
xiwoe c3e˜nei; C a b ApyraR KOHUenUMR- KOHUeIlUMfl HeABM-
TT
OH^
˜ ˜ M H ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ C ? X H O C MoxeT Aame 3apa60˜a˜b. paccwraHa
He T ˜ R XMMOCM K K U˜OXHO!?
a BeUM.
2) OTHOCMTenbHO
Elqe OAHMM BaXHblM MOMeHTOM n H T R
3 e ˜ e n b ˜ o yqama, K O T O P ˜ IHaxoAMTcfi B
ro ˜ Ha KnaccMrecKMe CMTyauMu: nepeoHa.ranbHo O RM
He/JBMXMMOCTM no 3aKOHOpaTenbCTBy Ka3ax-
YacroK, a B no-
Clamoi CO˜CTB˜HHOCM, npeflmaenneTcsl3e˜enb˜b1i
AOnXHbl6bmb 3aKO-
CneAyloueMO o ˜ ˜ ˜ C ˜ ˜ @ T ˜ ˜ M H ˜ , O , I ˜ ˜ X H K W I M M . npaeosoi pemnhn, K O T O P ˜ I ˜ ˜
nonomeHmrl o TOM, H craHa RenfieTcR
HoAaTenbHo 3a˜penne˜b1
Y Hac me mena ˜ e c r npRMo o 6 p a ˜ cwTya-
˜a˜ rpawaii-
vro ece npowe BeuM, sb˜crynaloq˜eKaqe- o
B ycTaHosneH p , n ˜
AaHHoro 06beK˜a
m e n p ˜ ˜ a m e x ˜ o c rxMenbHoro yqama, ˜ M RBoBnweHMeB 0 6 0 p o ˜ X ˜ n 0M0
: r HexMnoro CKMX npae.
ei?
@tga noenemo3a co6oi ˜ e o 6 x o f l ˜ ˜ m rnae˜&cocmsn˜ouei npaeoeoropawMa
ne-
MK-TO:3aMKHyTbleBrpaHMlJ,aX!PBcn<a BOAHble
HWBMXMMXM, no HalueMy MHeHMlo, R n e C
no- raflMxiUMMM BOBnfleHMeB060pO˜3e˜enbHbl˜ BRT R
06be˜˜t.1,
neca, 06qepacnpocrpa˜e˜˜b1e
cMcreua r o c y ˜ a p c r e e ˜ pew-
y'4aCNOB.3 ˜ K H nOMOub npMXwMTApyraR
ba ˜eficTeylo˜@R ˜oh
ne3HbleMCKOnaeMble- AOnXHbl npMHapCleXaTb
K O H U ˜ ˜ I & ˜ R - K O H ˜ ˜ H R C I ˜ O & n.1 cTpaUw npae H ˜ e eK ˜ yxe 6bmo omwetio
. K
CO˜CTB˜HHMK˜CO
B e M BblTeKaloUplMMOTClona
CM a
WIL(M.
C . 121r BK ˜ . ˜ ˜ C I B ˜ U I O X H O R OnpepeJ'IReT
K
T BeulM
npaBOBblMMIlOCJlWCTBMflMM; PaHee, M e H BOCO˜˜HHOCMX
MH O roCyAapmeH-
3) npaeoeoi p e m w H˜BMXMMOCM aon- H O perMcrpauMM npas Ha HeAsMxwMocrb M
CMTyal(MIO, KOrAa piuHOpOAHbleWU$4
o6pa3ylo˜ ˜
XeH, 6e3yUIoBH0, y.lMTblBaTb& KTF3XBeHHble pemcrpauMM npae Ha npMpaeHMBaeMble rK
w w o e uenoe, K
no3eon˜loqee
˜cnonb30ea˜b
no H ˜ ˜ H ˜ . ˜ ˜ H M I o ,
ero onpeaenReMoMy cyue-
csoAcrea M 3aKnloClaTbCR B A Y OCHOBHblX
BX HeABMXMMblM BeuaM BO3WUIHblX M M P K X
OCM
MOMeHTaX: C B M COeAMHeHMR, O M PaCCMaTPMBalOTCR
TO H cyAOB, cyAOB BHWHHerO BOwOrO IlMBaHMR,
ee cyno˜
nnaBaHMR ccpe˜a- ope)),
8 Ka3axcra˜e aBTOpOM m
R
KaK OpHa
a ) ˜ o n w 6bmneranb˜03a˜penne˜a
a KOH- KmMwecKMx
H A M M O T R n e C K.M. k l n b f l c o ˜ a ˜ ˜ . 117 rK),
O ˜ ˜ ˜ KM M OO MMyqeCTEa (n. 2 C .
e B X M C M BRT R TOBHr T
Cp K M O O , Cr HeABMXMMOCbIOflBnRDTCR
r Y u R T M rO
no HaUeMy MHeHMlo, oco6e˜-
K HCl l
O u n&R CJlOX-
3e˜enb˜b1i
yracroK M ero npwtiamexHocrM, MKnk3ialoTCRHaM60neecy˜KlBeHHble
KOTOPble n O l O CBR3aHbl C 3e˜Jlei;
P CH H O BeqM m n HQBMXMMO˜˜M 3 a ˜ n t o r a e ˜ c ˜ HoCM n H M H R M CTPYlCryPbl HWBMXMMOrO
OM aM
˜ B
6) npmo6- CnWyloueM. n p peanmxiuwnnpae Ha HeAeM-
˜
npasa H HeflBMXMMOCTb, MX
a MMyueecrea. n p o ˜ n n l o c r p ˜ p yTOT ˜
e˜ e ˜
(npeyqe Bcero H ˜ e ˜ e n bp ˜ b
a- ˜ iA ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ Y MKOHomTenbcTeOM PK.
X M M ˜
peTeHMe, ocyuecseneHMe M npeKpaueHMe, a IO˜MM
˜ a n p ˜ ˜ y l o C R T o c y ˜ a p m e ˜pem-
˜˜BM or CTOK)
npasoo6na,˜a˜e,nbn p e ˜ ˜ y q e c r e e t i ˜ o
(
˜oi rocy˜apcrse˜˜ylo
perwpaunlo npas Ha
C O ˜ ˜ ˜ B ˜ H H M K c a O M b pa3nmHbli
MOXeT Y) H B T
T
crpauMn. HwBMXMMOe MMY˜KIEO
MOXHO Onpe.4WMTb
K O H I J ˜ ((3e˜enbHblky.la˜˜o˜-rnaBHaRnpasoeoi p e x m ˜ F pas˜blx T P Y K ˜ P H ˜ I X ny6n˜r˜o
˜˜R C
I KK
a ocyqmnrrewylo npvl n o c m -
-
Beub, a B e npOClW, W T C O A Hepa3pblBHOC
Oe H !
C 3neMeHTOB. KOTOPble COCTaBnRloT KOHKpeTHOe nseopratios O ˜ ˜ ˜ C T B ˜ n aH O ˜ ˜
s H m rnacHoe
HepSMxuMoeMMyqemo. H a n p ˜ ˜ e p ,˜ e n b -
H MC R H , R n e C er0 nPMHweXHOCrblo)>
M B M O BRT R se yreepweHwe coeAMHeHnrr seqnoro npaea
nMua c M H A M B M A ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ H O - o n p e ˜ e n e ˜
˜ b ˜ i M M ˜ ˜ T O ˜ Hnpaecx16nafla˜en˜.
yacToK O˜O
AOnXHa C a b UeHTpaflbHblM 3BeHOM npaB0-
TT Be-
-
˜ o r o exma
p Bo Apyroro MnM
Hep,eMxMMoro MMyuecrBa B03BeAeHHOe Ha HeM 3 , q a ˜ ˜ e qblo. P ˜ W C T ˜ ˜ ˜ R C ˜ ˜ O C O ˜ C T B ˜ ˜ T ˜
APYMX. B 3 O Uly'4aeeAMHOe n H T e HwBM- UIeAyIOlqMX ueneh:
B R O Uly-lae TOrO, KOTOP˜I˜?
CKM OPMeHMPOBaH TM O RM
H 6 y ˜ y u e e a3s˜me
a p rpaqa˜c˜o-npaeoeblx X M C M K K 6b1paCnaQa'2TcR H HeCKOnbKO
M OT a a a) ($MKCaL(MM MOMeHTa B03HMKHOBeHMR
˜ e i B ˜ e c c TeM p e a n ˜ 3 a q ˜ cocraennroqMx: 3 e ˜ e n b ˜ b lYacroK RBnReTcsl
. seqiioro
c
OTHOUI˜HM˜ ˜e ˜ R npaea. klnare rosopR, pemcrpaunn
nonoxeHMR H npaKMKe 6 y ˜ 3 a ˜ p y ˜ - OAHOR seublo, 3 n a ˜ - Apyroi. K a w b l r i

3˜0ro a ˜e npaB H He/l,BMXMMOcTb MMeeT npaeoo6pa-
a
HeHa B cMny OnpeaeneHHbix, n p e w e scero M 3 M O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O B CaMOCTORTenbHOe
3 TX HMeeT 3ylouee 3 ˜ a r e ˜ ˜ e ;
KaK N R 06opora, T K M /3JlR OCy-
M T p C C M flpM'iMH. C o/˜,Ho˜
C OM l K X
e CTOPOHbl, K K
a 6 ) n y 6 n ˜ r ˜ o T.e. 0 H n CM BeqHoro
3˜areHMe, a m, aM l M
BeuM M WR uenei
u m n e H M f l npae Ha ˜ T M npaea H onpeAeneHHylo eeub y KoHKpemoro
yXe 6b1noyKa3aHO H M PaHee, 3eMeJlbHble
aM a
Jlklua CTaHOBMTCfl M3BMHblM BCeM, O C O ˜ ˜ H H O
YClaCTKM CTaJlM OCHOBHblMM CTPYKTyPHblMM rocy˜apCTBeHH0h
PerMCTpaUMM npaB H H X
a M.
O C O ˜ ˜ H3 O HarnRAHO npORBnReTCR B no-
HO
3neMeHTaMM COBpeMeHHOrO nOHRTklFI HeABM- T 3aMHTepeCOBaHHblMnMuaM; 0) MHj3,MBMP.YanM-
c gpyroi - nocTcoBeTcKMe peanw H T M KOHflOMMHMYMa, K T P e yXe O ' a T
RM OOO T4 C M
XMMOCM, 3 U M M KOHKpeTM3aUMM flpaBOBOr0 peXMMa
aM
B onpeaenetiiiblx cnyqanx Mcmlo'ialoT n p ˜ - 6bmo 3ZiTpoHyTO HaMM. 8 3 O UIy'4ae Mbl KaK
TM H@7,BMXMMOrOMMy˜eClBa. 6 b e ˜ perM- ˜ ˜
0 ˜a
crpaUMMRB˜ROTCROnpWeneHHbleB W ˜ q6b-
MeHeHMe 3 ˜ 0KOHl$3luMM. n p e w e BCerO 3 O I
i T pa3 MMeeMCnOXHylo Beqb, K T P l 06pa3yIO˜
O O YO
HeCKOnbKOC C a n I L , X
O T B RO UM :
KX M ˜ M ˜ H O ˜ (
caepe mrpaxqa˜)
˜ eKTMBHblX rpaX.4aHCKMXnpaB Ha HeABMXMMW
OTHKMTCR
1) KBaPMPbl#/MnM
M 3AaHMRM, COOPYXeHklRM M nPfXT0 nOMeue- HeXMnble IlOMeueHMR, MMy˜KlBO, M3MeHeHMe M npeKpaueHMe B
MX
H R , KOTOPble MCnOnb3YOTCR no HeXMnOMy
MM RBnRK)LL(Mecsl
CaMOCTORTenbHblMM O ˜ W K T ˜ M M ,pe3ynb˜a˜e
WenOK M M H ˜ I X ) P ˜ M ˜ ˜ c K M x ( ˜ )
K
o6qee MMyueCTBO, 1 M 2 cr. 2 Y˜a3a r o c y ˜ a p m e n ˜ o i ?
"0
Ha3Ha'ieHMO. ˜ c w I K ) ' - I ˜M M ˜
H TpaWaHCKOrO
3 2) K T p e npqHa-
OOO T E (n.n.
O
perMcrpauw npae Ha HWeMxmMoe˜ ˜ y q e c m o
o6opo˜a
3eMenbHblX Y'iaCTKOB npMBen0 K 3 ˜ a ˜ l ˜ ˜ l 0 l o 6 c n y x ˜ s a ˜ elu f l i nepeoi
e˜ f sl te
M a e n o c HMM");
˜
T M , CO M e H 3AaHMflMC O Y e M CTanM
OY T l MH O O P XH R KaTerOpMM (noAbe3fib1,nOABanbl, n H M KOM-
MM
˜ e u e h˜ P M
. r) perMcrpawR ocyqecTBnReTcrr ny-reM
- MYHMK˜˜M˜˜
BblcTynaTb B Kaqecme rnasHblx M T.R.),
3 M O ˜ ˜ ˜ K TnOBneKJla 2 co6oi COCTaBneHMR 0c06oro IlMCbMeHHOrO BKTa,
3) 3e˜WIbHblfi 4aCTOK, Ha KOTOPOM PaC-
BT 3! i
a M a&R TX y'
OB
cBweTenbcreyer o cyqmoeaHMM
nonaraem coomemeyloqee 3 n a ˜ M /e ˜ M
˜M
IlpaKTMCleCKM aBTOMaTM'ieCKOe HaAeneHMe ˜o˜opb˜h
coopyxetlne. BeuHoro npasa;
lopwqectwM mTynoM H BnaAeme 3 e ˜ e n b -
a


f l o M n e e c ˜ .Mnbscosa K. Pemcrpau˜s
: npas Ha
Z5
perucrpauw npae H a H e n s n x M M o e MMY-
OT
LU,eCTeo:
1) O ˜ ˜ ˜ K TperMCTpaUMM a B M X M M b l X B e -
OM
uefi RBnRloTCR OHM CaMM, a H e I l p a B a , KOTOPble
cyUecTBylOT H a 3 M B e u M ;
2) noao6˜an e r M c r p a U m R H e MMeeT npa-
p
BOflOpO˜alolqerO3Ha'4eHMR, HO RBnReTCR
H ˜ O ˜ X O ˜ M M ˜ nOBMeM O C y ˜ e C T B n e H M f l
YC I M
f l p a B a C O ˜ C T B ˜ H H OM MHblX B e u H b l X n p a B
˜˜M
Ha 3T0 M M Y U K E I O .
nocneg˜wfi Te3MC f l O A T B e p X A a e T C R fl.
1 cr. 8 3 a ˜ o ˜ a c n y 6 n ˜ a 3˜ x c r a ˜ 30
Pe K˜ a OT
M l o H R 1 9 9 8 r. N? 254-1 "0 pemcrpauw 3 a n o r a
a B M X M M O r 0 M M ˜ L U , K T B ˜ ' ' COrnaCHO KOTOPO-
˜˜,
MY npasosoe 3 ˜ a ' i e ˜ n p e m c r p a u M M 3 a n o r a
e
ABMXMMOrO M M y u e C T B a COcrOMTB TOM, 'iTOOHa
ycraHasnMsae-r-orlepeLlHocrb(nary) ynoene-
˜˜ope˜uarpe60˜a˜˜a3anoroaepxa˜ena no
OTHOWeHUK, K T P ˜ ˜ ˜ B ˜ H M I I M X 3M0-
npp

3e˜eJLbHblfi LJWlCmOK- zJLctBHaR 8eLlj,b, 8Ce nTOW?e, w e p x a ˜ e n e inpe-reHmunxHa p(acrHoe
,
UhlyUeCrBO3aJlOrOMTeJla B COOTBeTCTBMM C
W l l O meCH0 U HepU3pblBHO C HUM CBX3CLH0, rK M a P Y r M X 3aKOHOaaTenbHblX
nOnOXeHMRMM
˜ s n ˜ e ezo n˜ u ˜ a ˜ n e x ˜ o c r n b m .
mc p alcros. f l p ˜ ˜ a x q b ˜npenurecrsyo˜˜fi
TOM fi
m e-
3 a p e r ˜ c r p n p o e a ˜ ˜ b a n io r o a e p x a ˜ e n b
31f
( Q o ˜ M ˜ ) , M no C O a e p X a H M l o . ECJlM B
A) e T n p M o p m e T n p M 0 6 e c n e q e ˜ 1 . 1M c n o n H e H m
˜
a O K Y M e H T 0 perMcTpaL&4M BeuHOrO HMlo TaK
I rocy,,qapme˜˜ofi 0 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e n b c r enepen e c e M M n o c n e A y o q M M M
n e p e o M cnyqae O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T ˜ M M
npaea paccMaTpMsaeTcR B Ka'iecrse o c H o e H o r o a
j ˜ o ˜ a 3 a ˜ e n b ero˜Cay q e m o B a H M n . nocnw- 3apeMCrpMpBaHHblMM3anOrOaepXaT‚¬?JlRMM,a
p e r M c r p a U M M s b l c r y n a l o T npaea, TO eo BTOPOM
cr
- CaMM B e U M . Hanpki˜ep,n. 1 CT. 13 3 a ˜ 0 ˜ a T a m e flepea BCeMM He3aprMCTPMPOBaHHblMM
HeeMMeeTcyUeaBeHHOe3HareHMe f l p M 3auMl-e
P e c n y 6 n K a 3˜ x c r a 0 ˜ 1 5 f i e K a 6 p R2001roAa
˜˜ a 3 a n o r o a e p x a ˜ e A a˜ ˜ o r o M M y u e c r s a .
n HH˜
BeUHblX flpaB, f l p M PaCnOpRXeHMM n p a B O M M ˜
6 K a W C T B e BblBOAOB M O X H O 3aKJllOqMTb
N 271-11 "0 rOCy,JJapCTBeHHOM PerynMpOBaHMM
cmsyaunnx. !
j˜pymx
cnenylouee:
B C E O 0 O'iepeAb r p a m a ˜ c ˜ o fsi v l a u ˜ r˜p "a m a H c K M e e o 3 -
a B M X M M b l e B e u M . KaK M b l a ˜˜
1) B 3 a ˜ o ˜ o a a ˜ e n bP e˜ e y G n ˜a 3˜x -
c r cn K˜a
A y l u H b l e c y A a Pecny6n˜˜m 3 a x c r a ˜ npaea H a
yXe OTMWanM, M O X H O K J ˜ ˜ c c M $ M U M ˜ B ˜ T ˜ Ha Ka ,
HMX ˜ a e n o s e˜ l , a e M b l e c ˜ ˜ / n o pn l,e m a T
c˜ p u
pae K a T e r o p w : CTaH 0 H ˜ B M X M M O C r M AOJVKHa 6 b l ˜ b e a n ˜ 3 o -
p
˜˜ J
B a H a B Ka'iecTBe o6uero npaema KoHuenqMR
1) n B M X M M b l e B e U M , NflKOTOPblX ˜ ˜ 6 x 0 0 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e n b ˜ o f i
- rocyaapcrse˜˜ofi pemc-rpauMM
( ( 3 e ˜ ˜ b ˜ b a c T o K e c r b r n a s H a q sew, a sce
A n M a p e r m c r p a u w g . B TOM cnyae crMTaeTcR, ylfi
YnOnHOMO'ieHHblM O p r a H O M B r 0 C y Q a p C T B e ˜ -
HOM peec˜pep a m a H c K M x B O ˜ ˜ Y U J H C YX O B flpO'iMeCOCTaBflR0˜e nOHKMR H W H X M M O C M
YTO f l p a B 0 ˜ 0 f P e X M M ABMXMMOcTM f l p M p a B -
i ˜I ˜
r
P e c n y 6 n ˜ ˜ ˜˜ ˜ x c rT ˜ y f l. a p c ˜ ˜ e ˜ ˜ o h 1cr. 117 rK) e c r b ero npMHa,qnexHom));
(n.
K˜ oc H
HeH K f l p a B O B O M y P e X M M y H e a B M X M M O r O
2) KOHueflUMR C ˜ O X H O B e q M A O n X H a
pernc˜paunefi e n R e T c R npoueaypa y r e T a ˜
MMyUecrBa; R
2) A B M X M M b l e B e U M , m R KOTOPblX rpa- YnOnHOMO'ieHHblM O p r a H O M n p a B a C O ˜ C T B ˜ H - 6 b l ˜ PaCCMOTPeHa B Ka'iMBe MCKJlloLfeHMR H 3
b
HOCM M npymx npae, a T a K m e 0 6 p e ˜ e ˜ e H M h o6uero n p a B M n a M M O X e T 6 b l ˜ bl p M M e H e H a f
W a H C K M M 3aKOHOAaTenbffBOM YCTaHOBneH
o 6 4 ˜ hl p a B 0 ˜ 0 hp e X M M , H e ˜ p e 6 y I O u M f i H a r p a m a H c K M e BO˜,QYUIH˜I˜ a , B rocynap- M BCnyaRx:
f
a) n p R M 0 npej3,yCMOTpeHHblX B 3aKOHe;
CTBeHHOM peeffpe r p a W a H C K M X BO3,4YLLlHblX
pemcrpauMM.
6) n p M YCTaHOBneHMM npMCBOeHHOCTM
˜ ˜ B M X M M e u Ik l˜ m F l KOTOPblX H ˜ O ˜ X O - cyaos Pecny6nn˜˜ 3 a x a - a ˜ .A ˜ a n o r v l r ˜ b ˜ e
B˜ , Ka
3 e ˜ e n b ˜ o y o m a M ero np˜˜ap,nem˜ocrefi
ra
RMMa perMCTpal&lR, M O r P 6 b l ˜ b eCbMa p a 3 -
B flpaBMJla flpe)JyCMOTpeHbl m R aBTOMOTOTpaHC-
RM'iHblMM. fl. 2 CT. 117 r PK KTaKOBblM OTHOCMT:
K p a 3 H b l M JlMUaM;
nOPTHblX c ˜ ˜ C T B ˜ .
3) flOHRTMe HeflBMXMMOCrM M M W T M W P -
no H a w e M y MHeHMlo, r o c y A a p c r e e H H a f i p e -
B03)JYLLlHble M MOPCKMe C Y m , c n B H Y p e H H e r O
ya
l2
xapatnep, a B e u M , y ˜ a 3 a ˜ ˜ bn.e e
B o a t i o r 0 nnaeawn, cyaa n n a e a H M R ((peKa- nb˜ealo˜˜fi
M C r P a u M R A B M X M M O r O MMyU(ecrsa n p e C i l e a y e T
CT. 117rK,A O n X H b l npM3HaBaTbCRABMXMMbIMM
w t t b i e uenm M H e RsnReTcR a H a n o r o M perncr-
Mope)), ˜ o c ˜ M ' i e ˜ K M e 0 6 b e ˜ ˜ M l3TOM 3aKO-
npb .
no B e U a M M , KOTOPble K T O M y Xe M M e O T n p a B 0 ˜ 0 f i
paunn npae H a H e a s m x M M o e M M ˜ U ˜ ˜ T B O .
HOAaTenbHblMM aKTaMM K H w B M X M M b l M B e U a M
CyLU,effBy, ee M O X H O H a 3 B a T b T ˜ X H U ' ˜ ˜ C K OP e X M M , 0 ˜ n M ' i H b l h OT flpaBOBOrO peXMM.3 H e -
MOXeT 6 b l ˜ OTHeCeHO M MHOe MMYLU,efIBO.
b ˜
p e m c r p a ˜ ˜OnpeP,eJleHHblX˜MXnMblX ˜ B M X M M ˜ I eeuefi;
ei X
fl0 HaLLleMy MHeHMlo, CJleAyeT B A a H H O M
4) H‚¬!.4OnyCTMMO PaCCMaTPMBaTb M Oflpe-
BeUei. T a K a R P e r M C T p a u M R M O X e T BnMRTb
cnyae p a 3 a e n ˜ ˜OHRTMR: ˜b
1) p e r M c T p a U m npae H a H e A e w x n M o e n m u b H a o c y q m e H u e r p a m a H c K M x npae, )JenRTb B Ka'ieCTBe Hf2)JBMXMMOrO MMyU$XTBa

HO H e H a LIX BO˜HHKHOB˜HU˜, ˜ e m u e npennpmme (cr. 119 TK), K o T o p o e cneayer
n3˜e ˜n
HMYUCCTBO;
2) p e r M c r p a 4 M R a e n x n M o r o M M y q e c r e a . npelcpalqeclue. onpe,qenRTb B Ka'iemBe MMyqeeCTBeHHoro KOM-

a e ˜ y YKasaTb, 'iT0 A a H H b l e T e P M M H b l H e
e˜ T ˜ K M 0 6 p a 3 0 ˜ , perMCTpal(nRQBMXMMblx
M IlneKCa, CO‚¬TORUerO M3 Pa3HOPOaHblX O ˜ ˜ ˜ K T O B
r p a m a H c K v l x npae (cr. 115 TK). [%
c o s n a ˜ a l o ˜ y r c a p y r o M KaK no onpeaene-
Ap M M e e T A B a n p M H u M n M a J l b H b l X OTnM'iMR

r.
npasna, OT 29 ˜eKa6pfl2OOl N?300-301.
Ka3axcra˜c˜an
* CM.: npa˜blfla o c ˜ A ˜ ˜ C T B ˜ H H O R aBTOMOTOTpaHCflOpTHbIXCpeUClB 4 npHUenOB K HHM B PKIl$nHl
˜ perHCTf3aL(HH !
Ka3axcraH or 24 HIOHR 1996 r. N 217.
!
PKfly6nHK˜
1998 r.
Ka3axcra˜c˜an
npasua, 8 8˜lonfl
28